Erdrtyu
Main Eventer
Joined on: Mar 9, 2007 19:07:14 GMT -5
Posts: 4,291
|
Post by Erdrtyu on Jun 25, 2010 13:36:27 GMT -5
|
|
Erdrtyu
Main Eventer
Joined on: Mar 9, 2007 19:07:14 GMT -5
Posts: 4,291
|
Post by Erdrtyu on Jun 25, 2010 13:37:58 GMT -5
Look, I'm sorry about the CJ entering thing. But really, come on. This show was just for fun, it's not like this was a WPF show where wins and losses matter, or championships are on the line. It was just for fun. Sorry if I made anyone mad with that call.
Anyway, my votes:
Awesome Powers vs. Sh3rb1 Awesome: Yikes, sorry but this just isn't good. No way around that. The head looks terrible, really scrunched and too distorted. And it looks like no modifications were made at all. The attire isn't any better. The design is crudely cut out and just looks bad. Besides, that's not how his attire looks. At least you tried though, you could've just done a recolor and stopped, which is worse.
Sh3rb1: Beautiful figure. Really. The head looks incredible, big fan. It unfortunately looks as if you made no other modifications to the figure. Would've liked at least an attire recolor.
Vote: Sh3rb1, for the just all around better figure.
Jack vs Alexgg1
Jack: Another great figure here. The head is not incredible, but is pretty damn good. All the designs look great, and fit great on the figure. They do look a little blurry though, but that is just a minor gripe.
Alex: Not a fan. The head isn't good at all, and also distorted. The shirt just looks bad, I don't know how you did it but it's wrong. The black seems to be poking out from under the orange all over. The orange on the bands is way too bright. The shoes are also crudely colored. Too geometric-shaped, not organic at all.
Vote: Jack. Better, cleaner figure. Nice job bro.
BDTTK vs. Gazza vs. Kody vs. CJ
BDTTK: Pretty cool figure. The head does look good, but there's something off about it. I don't really know why though. The attire is beautiful, the design was added flawlessly. The knee pads look cool too, nothing to complain about there.
Gazza: Another really cool figure. The head certainly isn't your best work. It does show signs of rust. That being said, it's still a pretty good head. The attire is simplistic, but it works. Nice job on the boots, that's a small detail that most would've left off.
Kody: Very good head. The best in this match really. The one little problem is that it looks a bit undersized. I really like the hair. The attire looks pretty cool, and good to see the designs don't cover the joints at all. Very cool figure, only real gripe is the size of the head.
CJ: I wont include you in the voting, as to not make the others mad. But I do want to comment on the figure, as it is very cool. The head is OK, looks too over blurred however. I love the hair, and really makes up for the face. The jacket is modded flawlessly, I just love the whole look of it. The elbow pads look pretty weird, and are something I would've just left off. Big fan of the figure though.
Vote: Very difficult decision, but I give the nod to Kody. Best all-around figure here. Very close match up, and great work from all participants.
Again, thanks for all the hand-ins, sorry if I made anyone mad with the CJ situation, and good luck to all.
|
|
|
Post by gazzarko on Jun 25, 2010 13:51:07 GMT -5
I might aswell vote because im going to guess that alot of the "new people" that will vote don't have a clue what they will beon about.
Awesome Powers vs. Sh3rb1- Vote here goes to Sh3rb1 simply because its alot more realistic. The head is better since Awesome Powers dosnt even have looked to edit it. The attire is alot better, on awesome powers the cuts of the designs and boots are bad.
Jack vs. Alexgg1 Jacks is one of the best handed in. The attire is good, the kickpads are sick.The head is quiet good too. Alexggs isnt too bad but the shirt isn't great, it looks poor quality and un realistic. Good effort from both guys though.
Erdrtyu vs. The Mountain King Eh,Though one here both are good efforts.But I'm going for Mountain king because i like the head. even though the shirt isn't great, the head is good work.
|
|
Jack.
Main Eventer
Probably out Skating
Joined on: Feb 23, 2009 11:06:38 GMT -5
Posts: 4,907
|
Post by Jack. on Jun 25, 2010 14:48:59 GMT -5
Match 1:
Awesome Powers: It's a nice attempted and I can see what you were going for but the head is mishapen and not edited. Decent attempt.
Sh3rb1: Good figure, not much editing towards the attire but the head is very good, good job.
Winner: Sh3rb1
Match 2:
Jack: quite proud of this fig.
Alex: It's good, I a fan of the shirt and the belt is good as is the necklace but the head looks a big strange towards the mouth and the shoes aren't recolored too cleanly. good job though.
Match 3:
Erdrtyu: A good figure, remembering that the figure you are bacing this on it basic so it's hard. I wish you would've modded a head. and the head actually looks a bit small, the torso and bottoms are good.
The Mountain King: The head is good but there's something about it that doesn't look alot like stone cold. The shirt is ok but it's cut weird. Good job still as the head looks figure like.
Winner: Erdrtyu
Match 4:
BDTTK: A good figure, Very good and figure like head, the attire is amazing and I love the short boots. Good job on yhr knee pads too.
Gazza: Good figure, the head is good, dunno what's up with the bkack on the neck tough. The hands looks good as do the elbow pads, nice job on the tights. and the kickpads are good too.
Kody: Very good head, especially the hair, attire is perfect too. and, it's a smalld etail but the boots are excellent.
CJ: Very good head but there's something about that left eye. Aweseome jacket, not much to do on the tights, good boots too.
Tough One
Winner: Kody
Great Show, I'd like to see more in the future.
|
|
|
Post by cjs. on Jun 25, 2010 18:41:24 GMT -5
Sh3rb1 - I like the head on the christian and the attire is done cleanly and well.
Jack - I really like the attire, something about it makes it stand out and well colour coordinated.
Erdrtyu - Gets my vote because the attire looks well done although I don't like the outside of the bottoms, good job on doing something creative though it gives you extra points over the stone cold which imo has been done in figure form too many times to make a photoshop figure of.
BDDTK, Gazza and Kody.. good luck.
|
|
The Mountain King
Main Eventer
the artist formerly known as FL<O>
Joined on: Feb 19, 2008 17:51:45 GMT -5
Posts: 3,222
|
Post by The Mountain King on Jun 25, 2010 20:17:50 GMT -5
Awesome Powers vs. Sh3rb1 my vote goes to Sh3rb1. Awesome's head looks pretty messed up.
Jack vs. Alexgg1 Alexgg1's cena is great, but the head ruins it. Jack gets the vote.
BDTTK vs. Gazza vs. Kody Kody gets the vote. his is overall the cleanest.
|
|
JXT
Main Eventer
Professional Wrestler JXT
Joined on: Dec 20, 2009 18:53:17 GMT -5
Posts: 2,628
|
Post by JXT on Jun 26, 2010 1:03:11 GMT -5
Sh3rb1's - now wat won this match for me is that he attempted a head and did alright with it too, i know he didnt do as much work as AP but his head and logo were just stuck on and not edited and his boots are rough.
Jack - His head is alright and his fig is solid and the logos are done well , where as alexG his shirt is orange but has dark squares in it, the head is wierd and the shoes dont sit right and are cut out badly.
Erdrtyu - his fig is nice and looks real where as the moutain kings head isnt too bad but the shirt is tacky and austin is wearing brown tights for some reason lol
|
|
|
Post by alexgg on Jun 26, 2010 5:55:40 GMT -5
Haha I failed at the head eh? The reason the shirts like that is becuase I used the clothify effect which clearly fails...
Awesome Powers vs. Sh3rb1 The head on ryder looks very weird, really squashed and blury, the christian looks great, but the colors are a lil off imo.
Erdrtyu vs. The Mountain King I really love the carlito, good work allthough theres something grey around it which looks odd but dosnt matter. The shirt on scsa didnt look very good, it was rough and I disliked the color change.
fatal 4 way, all are good, But for some reason I prefer Kodys, it looked pretty sweet. The head on CJ's was good but didnt quite fit imo.
|
|
|
Post by 2345 on Jun 26, 2010 18:48:56 GMT -5
I wish Mattel Would make that Carlito!
|
|
|
Post by heartbreakking on Jun 29, 2010 8:32:01 GMT -5
Do not argue guys, there really is no need, it is only graphic design. No body really had an advantage over the other, the better figure will win the match. Anyway, my votes are as follows: Awesome Powers Vs Sh3rb1My vote: Sh3rb1AP's Zack Ryder just is not happening. The head looks poorly cut and the legs looked rushed. Looks as though the figure has been made in MS Paint. Keep trying, if you would like help message me and I will gladly offer you tips on Photoshop. My rating: D- Whereas Christian looks as though a little thought and effort has been involoved. The head looks lovely, just lacking good positioning. The hair could also be better, perhaps cutting and pasting the hair from a real figure. There is also two much shadow down one side of the face, I suggest trying to tweak it using the curves tool. The attire is really nice, just maybe lacking in some highlights and shadows on the logo. Otherwise a top effort and great figure. My rating: B Jack Vs Alexgg1My vote: JackTyson looks really nice. Again im going to give you pretty much the same advise I gave Sh3rb1, maybe using curves to tweak the colour and highlights on the head. The attire looks really nice, abit pixelated in places however still decent. My Rating: C Cena's head looks blurred and pixelated, more around the eyes than anywhere else. The shirt looks good but the sleves are what puts me off. Simple figure really but not a bad job. The recolour on the shirt is pretty bad though. My Rating: C- Erdrtyu Vs M..KingMy vote: M KingE's Carlito is nice. Everything looks fine, however I can see a blue box around the figures legs which are offputting. Simple figure really, the attire is good, the logos over the joints do not look nice. I would make the logos from each joint a new layer and twist them and add shadows so they appear to be under the joint, as they would on a real figure. My rating: C SCSA, a really nice figure actually. The shirt looks fine, up until the neck, it is not the right shape for an Austin vest, and the colour from the skin is appearing through. The logo on the chest in nice. The head looks rather good, very figure like, not a scan I personally would choose for Steve, but it is well made. My rating: B- BDTTK Vs Gazza Vs Kody Vs CJMy vote: KodySkip, looks okay. Again I can see a blue box around the legs like the Carlito. The head is good, but pixelated around the edges. It's lacking in the shadows and highlights the body have so it does not match well. My rating: B- Gazza, Nice figure. Second place, very close to Kody's. The smudge on the groin is and off put. The head is nice, looks as though you have used to many highlights and in the wrong place, it looks too light for the body in places. My Rating: B Kody, tough one but I gave this figure the win. The head, especially the face, looks fantastic, fits on the body perfectly and the colours/tones match to a tee. The hair is okay, could have been made to look more plastic. The attire is again really good, nice to see you cut the joint out of the logo instead of just dropping it straight over the joint, perhaps overlay might have looked better on the logo? Otherwise lovely figure. My rating: B+ Nice attire CJ, looks really perfect. I love your figure just not the head. It looks two blurry and dark. Seems asthough you put far more effort into the rest of the figure and forgot about the head. Head rating: C Body rating: A My rating: B P.s Bret's back [/size]
|
|
|
Post by [MJH] on Jul 1, 2010 16:57:51 GMT -5
cleaned up post, if arguing persists I'll have to lock this.
|
|
Erdrtyu
Main Eventer
Joined on: Mar 9, 2007 19:07:14 GMT -5
Posts: 4,291
|
Post by Erdrtyu on Jul 2, 2010 12:17:47 GMT -5
Ok, about time we closed this. It's been a week, so I think everyone who was going vote already has. So here are the winners!:
Awesome Powers vs. Sh3rb1: Winner with 8 total votes, Sherb1. Jack vs. Alexgg1: Winner with 6 total votes, Jack.
Erdrtyu vs. The Mountain King: Winner with a vote score of 4-2, Erdrtyu.
BDTTK vs. Gazza vs. Kody vs. CJ: Winner with 4 votes, Kody.
Congrats to everyone, and let me know if you guys want to do this again or not.
|
|
|
Post by [MJH] on Jul 2, 2010 16:00:40 GMT -5
ok, nice job on the show. Locked.
|
|