Which set makes the best stable?

Elite 23

Elite 7 would dominate

I tried to do this more realistically. Obviously, E23 had some serious star power, but there would be no time period where all of them were active. I don't think Cesaro even debuted while Savage was still alive, so that's out. Not only that, but with the exception NWO, when you have major talent together, it doesn't last long.

While E27 was my initial thought since it hads a decent mix of upper-and mid-card talent, I can't really see a situation where Undertaker would make sense in that group. So, my pick would be the Tribute to the Troops series.

I could see them in a role where they "take back the WWE" from The Authority (or whatever major storyline would be going on at the time). Cena, Show, Mysterio, and Orton are all too tier guys, but they're also all able to carry out major storylines without a championship being involved. Not only that, but even though Show and Mysterio are major title contenders, they are both still viable IC/US title contenders. You could have Orton and Cena as the WHC and WWE champions respectively, and Show and Mysterio as either US/IC champs, tag team champs, or all of the above.

Is it a perfect stable? No. But I could see them making an impact and having lasting appeal.

Basic 20 would make a great stable. All different international superstars, it actually has a theme. And the world champions series with Eddie, SCSA, Punk, Warrior, Big show and Cena.

I have to agree on the wm heritage

Not Elite 5.