Oh man. "MicroLeague Wrestling" on the Commodore64.
The starter had Hulk Hogan VS. Paul Orndorff and Hulk Hogan VS. Randy Savage. Retail expansions had Randy Savage VS. the Honky Tonk Man, Hulk Hogan VS. Ted Dibiase, Hacksaw Jim Duggan VS. King Harley Race and Jake "The Snake" Roberts VS. Ravishing Rick Rude. I also ordered a fifth expansion that you could only get directly from the company; the Ultimate Warrior VS. Ravishing Rick Rude.
First one I can remember playing is In Your House on the Sega Saturn
I remember my brother bought IYH about a month before he actually bought his Playstation so all that time I was just dying to play what in my mind would be the greatest game of all time (I lived for the WWF at that age), no doubt just like my beloved WWF Royal Rumble on the SNES but new and up to date!