So I've put together a list of MOTYCs. I have a lot of 2009 BattlARTS coming in soon. I'll check those out and see if any of those belong on the list. Most of these I've already seen but some are just from multiple peoples' reviews.
Needs some more lucha. But those are the only two I've seen that stand out from 2009.
It also could use some more All Japan and New Japan. I have a lot of NJ to catch up on. But here's the list anyway.
NJPW 1/4/09 - Mitsuharu Misawa and Takashi Sugiura vs. Shinsuke Nakamura and Hirooki Goto
TNA 1/11/09 - Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett
NOAH 1/25/09 - KENTA vs. Kotaro Suzuki
CHIKARA 1/25/09 - Fire Ant and Soldier Ant vs. Amasis and Ophidian
Kensuke Office 2/11/09 - KENTA vs. Katsuhiko Nakajima
WWE 2/15/09 - Elimination Chamber Match: Edge vs. Triple H vs. Undertaker vs. Big Show vs. Jeff Hardy vs. Vladimir Kozlov
WWE 2/15/09 - Elimination Chamber Match: John Cena vs. Edge vs. Rey Mysterio vs. Chris Jericho vs. Kane vs. Mike Knox
NOAH 3/1/09 - Go Shiozaki and Takashi Sugiura vs. Shinsuke Nakamura and Milano Collection AT
NOAH 3/1/09 - Katsuhiko Nakajima vs. KENTA
AJPW 3/14/09 - Kaz Hayashi vs. Minoru
AJPW 3/14/09 - Minoru Suzuki and Taiyo Kea vs. Suwama and Shuji Kondo
CMLL 3/20/09 - Mistico vs. Negro Casas
CHIKARA 3/28/09 - Kota Ibushi vs. El Generico vs. Matt Jackson vs. Jigsaw
CHIKARA 3/28/09 - Bryan Danielson, Claudio Castagnoli, and Dave Taylor vs. Mike Quackenbush, Jorge Rivera, and Johnny Saint
ROH 4/3/09 - KENTA vs. Davey Richards
ROH 4/4/09 - KENTA and Tyler Black vs. Austin Aries and Katsuhiko Nakajima
WWE 4/5/09 - Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels
ROH 4/11/09 - Jerry Lynn vs. Bryan Danielson vs. Tyler Black vs. Austin Aries
ROH 4/18/09 - Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards vs. Bryan Danielson and Tyler Black
ROH 4/24/09 - Jerry Lynn vs. Roderick Strong
WWE 4/26/09 - Last Man Standing Match: John Cena vs. Edge
Zero1-MAX 4/29/09 - Daisuke Sekimoto vs. Ryouji Sai
PWG 5/22/09 - Young Bucks vs. Men of Low Moral Fiber
PWG 5/22/09 - Hybrid Dolphins vs. Young Bucks
CHIKARA 5/24/09 - Fire Ant and Soldier Ant vs. Icarus and Chuck Taylor
ROH 5/30/09 - Bryan Danielson vs. Tyler Black
WWE 6/7/09 - Ladder Match: Jeff Hardy vs. Edge
AAA 6/13/09 - Dr. Wagner Jr. vs. El Mesias
NOAH 6/22/09 - Go Shiozaki and KENTA vs. Kensuke Sasaki and Katsuhiko Nakajima
ROH 6/26/09 - Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards vs. KENTA and Roderick Strong
WWE 6/28/09 - Chris Jericho vs. Rey Mysterio
NOAH 7/12/09 - KENTA and Taiji Ishimori vs. Atsushi Aoki and Kota Ibushi
BJW 7/12/09 - Yuko Miyamoto vs. Masashi Takeda
DGUSA 7/25/09 - Hallowicked, Gran Akuma, Icarus and Amasis vs. Mike Quackenbush, Fire Ant, Soldier Ant and Jigsaw
DGUSA 7/25/09 - CIMA and Susumu Yokosuka vs. The Young Bucks
DGUSA 7/25/09 - Shingo vs. Naruki Doi
PWG 7/31/09 - Guerrilla Warfare: Chris Hero vs. Joey Ryan
NOAH 8/2/09 - Kenta Kobashi and KENTA vs. Go Shiozaki and Akihiko Ito
ROH 8/14/09 - KENTA, Bryan Danielson and Roderick Strong vs. Chris Hero, Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards
CHIKARA 8/16/09 - Jigsaw, Equinox and Helios vs. Chuck Taylor, Vin Gerard and Stigma vs. Fire Ant, Hallowicked and Arik Cannon
WWE 8/23/09 - TLC Match: CM Punk vs. Jeff Hardy
PWG 9/4/09 - Bryan Danielson vs. Chris Hero
DGUSA 9/6/09 - Bryan Danielson vs. Naruki Doi
DGUSA 9/6/09 - Shingo vs. Davey Richards
CHIKARA 9/13/09 - Mike Quackenbush and Jigsaw vs. Bryan Danielson and Claudio Castagnoli
ROH 9/18/09 - Bryan Danielson vs. Chris Hero
ROH 9/25/09 - Bryan Danielson vs. Davey Richards
ROH 10/9/09 - Davey Richards vs. Kenny Omega
ROH 11/13/09 - Austin Aries vs. Davey Richards
TNA 11/15/09 - Kurt Angle vs. Desmond Wolfe
TNA 11/15/09 - AJ Styles vs. Samoa Joe vs. Christopher Daniels
Everyone talks about KENTA and Davey Richards having a hell of a year. Danielson is right up there with them. He really kicked it into gear in his last month.
I was unsure on Kobashi/KENTA vs. Go/Ito from 8/2. But the match comes off even better on DVD, as I already highly enjoyed the download of it back in August. So I had to add it.
We probably need a MOTYC thread.