|
Post by alexgg on Feb 12, 2012 19:15:48 GMT -5
It's been 4 years since the first PPPV. The first PPPV under the reign of alexgg1. Now he returns to host the show that started it all, on the road to Stick-A-Mania.--------- Matches: GSC #1 Contendership Match Ben vs w.S.eWINNER: w.S.e 1 - 5Global Stick Championship Match. Nuke Storm vs SammyWINNER: Nuke Storm 5 - 0Ultraviolent Championship Match. Fav vs FUEGO vs TylorWINNER: Tylor 2 - 0 - 3World Stick Championship Match. alexggone vs -1888matt-WINNER: alexggone 4 - 2Congratulations to the winners, and thanks to those who participated.
|
|
|
Post by alexgg on Feb 12, 2012 19:31:25 GMT -5
Ben vs w.S.e
Ben: I like the creativity, but it is very stiff. w.S.e: The running is speedy tip toes, its kinda choppy and is also stiff. But not as stiff.
Both animations are good, but as stiffness goes... Vote: w.S.e
------------------------------------
Nuke Storm vs Sammy
Nuke Storm: Pretty quick, quite stiff but also has good movements and is different to watch. I like the rebounds. Sammy: Its pretty fast, not really enough frames and is kinda hard to tell what's happening...
I felt Sammy was pretty short, kinda confusing. Whilst Nuke Storms was more fun. Vote: Nuke Storm
------------------------------------
Fav vs FUEGO vs Tylor
Fav: Great animation, very smooth. Running could be a little better, but I loved the jump/airtime and the reactions were not bad. FUEGO: Good start, nice run up and awesome pose. I like the idea, but the airtime was too fidgety, quite stiff and overall floaty. A few frames too much perhaps, needed more impact. Tylor: Fantastic start, stiff yet very smooth. Good springboard. I think the airtime on the suplex itself lets the animation down, yellow needs much more movement and reaction.
I liked all 3 animations, Favvs for smoothness, FUEGOs for creativity and Tylors for a mix of the two. But I feel... Vote: Fav.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Sept 28, 2024 8:14:59 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 12, 2012 19:37:30 GMT -5
GSC no 1 contender, BEN: More creative GSC: good luck match 3: Tylor, smoother but stiff Match 4: 188matt, smoother
|
|
Tylor
Main Eventer
Joined on: Dec 23, 2008 18:17:08 GMT -5
Posts: 4,437
|
Post by Tylor on Feb 12, 2012 19:44:50 GMT -5
GSC #1 contender: w.S.e. Ben, yours was way too stiff. GSC: Vote: Nuke. Sammy's, your's was nice (thx for using my style ) but there was some stiff parts. Nuke, yours was stiff as well. Nuke used better creativity here. Sammy don't like how the black stick started already in the air. UV: Good luck. WSC: Vote: Alex. A really close one here. Alex had better reactions. Matt, your's kinda lagged on my little netbook. Which may of affected your vote, because it seemed slow.
|
|
|
Post by done on Feb 12, 2012 20:05:30 GMT -5
First Match - #1 Contender for the GSC Match
Ben - I like the thinking of this animation, it was a bit slow, the movement of the ladder was ok, I like the ring rope movement, maybe next time try and add a little jump lift in the powerbowb and make the black stick move a bit more. w.S.e - Running isn't so great, the ariel part was quite nice. Sell was ok but could of been better. Maybe space the legs out a bit more when running.
Both were pretty stiff, but my vote goes to: w.S.e Ben you were kidda close but you just needed a bit more force in the move and a proper sell. Nice try though both of you.
Ultraviolent Championship Match
Fave - The running was smooth but I didn't really like the way it was setting out but it was still ok. The sell was really nice - I liked the end to it. FUEGO - Loved the run down, the jump was good, but the drop into the tables was to straight and wasn't that realistic, but I liked how the stick had a little reaction. Tylor - The jump from the ring to the ropes and to the Prison was great, really like the suplex - had more power in it, but I think the land into the table kinda killed it since their was no reaction from yellow or brown.
Great job all of you. Vote goes to: Tylor Fave, this was really close but the running shouldn't of looked like the stick was dipping its feet.
World Stick Championship
alexggone - Really nice animation, loved the jump, the sell was nice. I really like how the cage had a bit of movement out of it since that happens in real life, really smooth animation. - 1888matt - Cool jump, nice ariel time, Not much of a sell but I see a bounce in it, this animation was also really smooth.
Great job to you guys, both very smooth anis. My vote goes to: alexggone -1888matt - you were close but you just needed more of a sell.
|
|
|
Post by thepedigree22 on Feb 13, 2012 16:54:32 GMT -5
MAtch 1 Vote Goes to W.S.E Wasn't a fan of either animations to be honest. W.S.e's was leff stiff had a better reaction/ Match 2 Vote Nuke Storm Sammy's was too short Nuke's was stiff and a bit choppy but i vote Nuke cause of creativity it was better than Sammy's Match 3 Good Luck Main Event Vote -1888matt- Great MAtch up! A blast from the past i guess. Alex your animation was really smooth but the flips were a bit stiff. And the fall it looks like his legs hit the mat first? It kind of slowed down.. MAtt great animation great air time! I liked your flips better than Alex's Sorry Alex it came close........... But Matt one by a little bit
|
|
|
Post by done on Feb 14, 2012 17:17:32 GMT -5
3 other peeps haven't voted (we know what happened to 1888matt)
|
|
|
Post by markusyeah on Feb 14, 2012 23:08:05 GMT -5
Voting for WSE here because it was smoother and had more movement in the joints - though you really should have picked a better color for the attacker (it was too similar to the background which made it hard to see). Ben yours was really stiff, like it you look at the attacker the legs didn't move at all and the back barely moved, try moving every joint in every frame to fix this the defender was better in this depertment but still need more consistent joint movement. It was choppy too, you should try throwing in a few more frames to smoothen it out
Voting for Nuke storm as it had a better speed. Nuke, your running looks quite weird, like you don't move the feet off the ground and the stick is just sliding along, besides that your moving the joints rather well so stiffness isn't too big an issue though like the running on the Green and clothsline on the Blue, there were a lot of fridgets though - you should try and make sure that all the frames flow together when making animations so that there aern't any out of place movements the speed was quite good though I felt it could have been slowed down just a bit. Sammy the main problem with your animation is that it's just hard to tell what's going on, you need to throw in a lot more frames to slow it down. Besides that though it seemed quite good, though there was some stiffness in places like the leg of the attacker during the punch and the defenders arms back during the fall. The black was a bit fridgety after the punch too, also to picture was too small with added to the confusion of what was going on. Honestly if your had been slower it would have easily had my vote.
Voting for Fav, there are some small problems in your animation like the running being a bit stompy and the back needing more movement during the running, the arm positioning being awkward during the flip and the Yellow being a bit fridgety but as a whole this animation is very good and though I haven't seen any of your recent animations, based on this I'd say your pretty close to being in contention for the world title. Fuego yours was looking really good up until the end, like the step into the move was a little awkward and there was some stiffness but nothing major. During the end though it got really fridgety and brang the animation down a lot, to avoid this in the future you should go through the frames while making the animation to make sure it flows together and there aren't any out of place movments. Besides that the speed was pretty good but could use a couple more frames here and there. But overall had it not gotten so fridgety you would have a very nice animation here. Tylor your one of the top animators here in my mind but this animation doesn't really show it. All up to the move was pretty good, though the first jump looked a bit weak and theres a bit of a fridget around the second jump, but yeah once it went into the move it kind of fell apart like the Red stick had no flow, it kind of jumped into the move stopped then continued, and the Yellow stick had no prep going into it and had a big fridget on the upside though it was really smooth and not too stiff. Had that part been better you easily would have won.
This one is really close but going to give Alex the vote, Matt yours was really good but that tuck that you did into the moonsault hurt the animation a lot for me, besides that there aren't a whole lot of other problems, like the arms look weird going into the tuck and the reactions could have been better, but it's really smooth and not at all stiff, Alex yours is good too, though the arms looked bit fridgety and I think the airtime could have used some more frames to make the flip a bit smoother but yeah besides that great animation.
PPV was pretty good in my mind, honestly at the moment any PPV that has 3 matches or more is a well done one.
|
|
Tylor
Main Eventer
Joined on: Dec 23, 2008 18:17:08 GMT -5
Posts: 4,437
|
Post by Tylor on Feb 14, 2012 23:40:02 GMT -5
Tylor your one of the top animators here in my mind This has been a really good ppv Alex. UV match is tied.
|
|
|
Post by -The Autistic Animator- w.S.e on Feb 15, 2012 0:29:10 GMT -5
GSC Title Match
Nucke Storm Vs Sammy
Nuke: Your Ani Was More Figety Of The Two But Your One Looked Better. When The Green Dude Got Clotheslined His Reaction Was Really Weird. Running Was Ok Was Smooth In A Way
Sammy: Yourt Ani Was Shorther And I Didnt Like That. Your Ani Was Smoother Than Nuke's But It Was Short And Thats What I Didnt Like. The Blue Guy Didnt Have Much Of A Reaction
Vote: Nuke Storm
Ultraviolent Championship Match
Fav Vs FU3GO Vs Tylor
Fav: Of Course This SSP Was Better Than Mine, The Running Looked Like Stomping But It Was Smooth And Where Did You Get The Sprite.
FU3GO: It Was More Spaceier Than Fav's But The Running Looked Like Running But It Wasnt Smoother Than Fav's But
Tylor: My Favorite Ani Of This Match Why. Its Smooth And If I Went Thorugh A Table Like That I Would Be Like That
Vote: Tylor
WH Title Match
Alexggone Vs -1888matt-
Alex: I Like That The Cage Shook But When The Dude Was About To Jump Just Looked Like He Had Just Shat Pants (Do Stick Figures Ware Pants). And The Reactions Were Weird. Overall My Favorite Ani Of This PPV
-1888matt- : The Moonsault Was Smooth But The Reaction Was Like Someone Falling Asleep Not Trying To Be Mean But. Yeah, The Jump Wasnt That Good The Purple Dudes Reaction Was M'kay
My Vote: ALEX
|
|
|
Post by done on Feb 15, 2012 16:14:12 GMT -5
Well Thank you to all who competed cause without you, this PPPV would of actually gone on. And Congrats to all winners!
|
|