Create a modern day 4 horsemen.

perfect!

I would like it if you swapped out Barrett for McGillicutty.

But a Four Horsemen like group was The Radicalz

Now that was a stable

Dean Malenko as the Flair of the stable
Chris Benoit as the Arn Anderson of the stable
Eddie Guerrero as the Tully Blanchard of the stable
Perry Saturn as the Barry Windham of the stable

Del Rio as the Leader

McIntyre & Dibiase as the Tag Team

Barrett as the Enforcer

Daniel Bryan
Cody Rhodes
Trent Barretta
Ry-Back

manager: Arn Anderson

Arn Anderson (Manager- JJ Dillon of this new Horsemen group, their mouthpiece)

Dolph Ziggler (He would be the Ric Flair of this new Horsemen group, the leader by having Arn pick him out by Arn saying how Dolph reminds him so much of a young Nature Boy Ric Flair in terms of having the beach blond hair, blue eyes, that cockiness, that swagger that Flair had, Ziggler possesses and Dolph would drop Vickie like a bad habit and Arn would start managing Dolph in his matches)

Cody Rhodes (The Tully Blanchard of the stable; Cody's dad The American Dream Dusty Rhodes was an enemy of The Four Horsemen, so wouldn't it be fitting for the son of The American Dream to join forces with Arn Anderson by Arn telling Cody that he reminds him of a young Tully Blanchard in terms of having that pretty boy arrogance that Tully used to have and Tully was the technician of the group and Cody is a technical wrestler which Arn admires and with Arn's guidance he can become even better)

Jack Swagger (The Arn Anderson of the stable; Arn would go on about how Jack Swagger reminds Arn of a younger version of himself way back when and that for a big man, Jack is quite the technical wrestler but under Arn's guidance Jack could become that much better not just as a wrestler but as a talker as well)

Skip Sheffield or Ryback as he is called now (He would be the Barry Windham or even like The Lex Luger of the stable in terms of he would be like the muscle that this group desperately needs, kind of like how Windham and or Luger were in WCW in the 80s, Ryback would be that today)

Now this you have to admit would be a pretty formidable stable, Diamonds would truly be forever and so would The New Horsemen

Throw up the 4 Horsemen sign right now if you're down

I have to admit this would make a great Horsemen stable as well

Ted DiBiase
Michael McGillicutty
Drew McIntyre
Curt Hawkins

That's spot on for my current era 4H.The only thing I would add is Arn Anderson as their manager.Their has to be some ties to the original group.Ideally it would be Flair once he returns.