What about BOPPV and other Elite figures such as DM, All Stars, and RSE?
If you count those, here's the updated count.
Current roster
[10] Undertaker: (1, 8, 14, 18, 23, WM26, WM27, DM4, SDCC, 20-0)
[9] CM Punk: (1, 6, 11, 16, 20, All Stars, RSE, WM28, WM29)
[10] Rey Mysterio: (1, 5, 11, 13, 15, 18, 21, 24, RSE, WM26)
[3] R-Truth: (2, 10, 15)
[6] Randy Orton: (2, 9, 12, 16, 21, All Stars)
[6] HHH: (2, 7, 23, BOPPV1, DM3, COO)
[2] Ted Dibiase: (2, 10,)
[4] Christian: (3, 11, 20, BOPPV3)
[6] The Miz: (3, 9, 11, 24, WM27, WM28)
[11] John Cena: (3, 7, 11, 14, 17, 20, 23, BOPPV1, BOPPV3, DM5, Live Event KME)
[3] Cody Rhodes: (3, 13, 20)
[2] Santino Marella: (3, 20)
[5] Big Show: (4, 10, 13, 22, WM28)
[7] Kane: (4, 10, 12, 19, 22, RSE x2)
[4] Kofi Kingston: (4, 9, 17, WM27)
[2] Chris Jericho: (4, 20)
[4] Dolph Ziggler: (5, 13, 19, 24)
[2] Jack Swagger: (5, WM26)
[2] Mark Henry: (5, 15)
[1] JTG: (6)
[1] Hornswoggle: (7)
[1] Tyson Kidd: (7)
[1] Drew McIntyre: (8)
[5] Sheamus: (8, 13, 17, 25, BOPPV3)
[2] Evan Bourne: (8, 15)
[1] William Regal: (8)
[2] Zack Ryder: (9, 17)
[1] Yoshi Tatsu: (10)
[3] Wade Barrett: (11, 18, 24)
[3] Daniel Bryan: (12, 19, BOPPV1)
[3] Alberto Del Rio: (12, 14, 21)
[1] Justin Gabriel: (12)
[6] The Rock: (14, 16, 22, L3, DM2, WM27)
[4] Sin Cara: (15, 18, 25, BOPPV3)
[1] Ezekiel Jackson: (16)
[1] Heath Slater: (16)
[2] Brodus Clay (18, 25)
[1] Jerry Lawler (18)
[2] Brock Lesnar (19, WM29)
[2] Ryback (21, 24)
[1] AJ (21)
[1] Tensai (22)
[1] Damien Sandow (22)
[1] Antonio Cesaro (23)
[1] Seth Rollins (25)
[1] Dean Ambrose (25)
[1] Roman Reigns (26)
Non-current roster
[3] Bret Hart (DM5, BOPPV1, RSE)
[1] Diesel: (16)
[1] Kevin Nash: (16)
[1] Yokozuna: (15)
[1] King Booker: (14)
[1] Big Boss Man: (14)
[1] Papa Shango: (12)
[1] Luke Gallows: (9)
[1] David Hart Smith: (7)
[1] Shad: (6)
[1] Goldust: (6)
[1]Chavo Guerrero: (5)
[1] Vladimir Kozlov: (5)
[1] Finlay: (4)
[3] John Morrison: (4, 10, All Stars)
[2] MVP: (1, 9)
[3] Edge: (1, 8, 13)
[2] Batista: (2, 6)
[2] Matt Hardy: (2, 6)
[6] HBK: (3, 7, 19, DM1, Rockers, WM28)
[2] Mankind/Cactus Jack (17, RSE)
[1] Kelly Kelly (17)
[1] Miss Elizabeth (19)
[1] Honky Tonk Man (21)
[1] The Giant (22)
[1] JBL (23)
[1] Macho Man Randy Savage (23)
[1] Trish Stratus (24)
[1] Bruno Sammartino (25)
[1] Vince McMahon (Mailaway)