|
Post by ASR (therockisback) on Feb 1, 2023 21:36:26 GMT -5
Overrated? Underrated? Big draw? Big star? One of the best? One of the worst? Under appreciated? Legend? Icon? Glorified stuntman? Crap on the mic? Crap in the ring? Good on the mic? Good in the ring? Amazing talent?
I saw him get trashed in the other thread hahaa so I thought why not make this a discussion.
|
|
|
Post by The Brain on Feb 1, 2023 21:59:19 GMT -5
I was always a fan.Cactus Jack being my fav ''face''
So many classic feuds during that run...Sting,Vader,Trips,Sabu,Funk etc.
|
|
TheEvilDoink1987
Main Eventer
Joined on: Feb 22, 2010 21:37:52 GMT -5
Posts: 2,801
|
Post by TheEvilDoink1987 on Feb 1, 2023 23:33:33 GMT -5
I will never understand the "Mick Foley is a glorified stuntman" argument.
Yeah, he wasn't Bret Hart in the ring, but he had his own very unique style that allowed him to have excellent matches with wrestlers of all shapes and sizes. He didn't always have to jump off a cage to get a reaction.
Foley was also incredibly versatile. The original Mankind character was deranged and creepy, but then he was able to portray something totally different with Dude Love and a more comedic role later during the Mr. Socko era. He was always able to get an emotional response from the crowd which isn't easy.
Mick Foley isn't on my Mount Rushmore, but I have a ton of respect for him and question any real pro wrestling fan who doesn't.
|
|
|
Post by tmnt316 on Feb 1, 2023 23:36:01 GMT -5
Mick Foley isn't on my Mount Rushmore, but I have a ton of respect for him and question any real pro wrestling fan who doesn't.
|
|
|
Post by hbkbigdaddycool on Feb 2, 2023 0:34:49 GMT -5
I liked the WCW and ECW versions of Cactus Jack. I even liked the 1996 - 1998 Foley in WWF
But I didn't care for the Mankind character in the jogging pants and was like just Mick Foley pretty much wearing a mask and a white shirt with the jogging pants.
|
|
|
Post by hbkjason on Feb 2, 2023 0:41:58 GMT -5
I have always liked him. He was entertaining in the ring, he could have good matches with all different kinds of opponents and he could be a lot of fun too.
Plus, his first book is one of my all time favorite books.
|
|
|
Post by TKO Propagandist on Feb 2, 2023 2:35:12 GMT -5
The greatest main event jobber to the stars
|
|
|
Post by TheSystem 1.5 on Feb 2, 2023 3:39:23 GMT -5
Every fan should respect Foley. At the end of the day, he’s one of us. He was a fan that was passionate and loved the business. He destroyed himself just to make it in the business he loved even though the business didn’t want him. He was a inspiration to fans that wanted to wrestle but didn’t look like Rick Rude or wrestle like Bret Hart. If he could make it, so could you.
|
|
|
Post by cordless2016 on Feb 2, 2023 7:40:54 GMT -5
Love Foley. Was he a technical genius? No, but he knew how to tell great stories and put on 5* matches despite his lack of athleticism. And nobody can deny he wasn’t one of the biggest names during the Attitude Era. After Austin and Rock, it can be argued he was the #3 biggest name in the company for a time (even to the point many fans and analysts wanted WM15s main event to become a triple threat).
|
|
|
Post by MKSavage on Feb 2, 2023 10:11:13 GMT -5
Big fan of Foley, I thought he was very versatile. Cactus Jack was my favorite character of his, but Mankind and Dude Love were also fun. Like others have said, he was able to have a good feud/match with just about anyone. I've said a few times that he was probably the sleeper MVP of the WWF during the attitude era. Yes, there were definitely bigger stars, but he was in a high-profile feud with all of them and it was always entertaining (Taker, HBK, Kane, Austin, Rock, Triple H, New Age Outlaws, etc.)
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Nov 23, 2024 6:31:46 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 2, 2023 11:38:24 GMT -5
tons of respect!
wasnt a huge fan of his Cactus Jack WCW days, but LOVED Mankind, esp early Brown Mankind. Dude Love was fun too.
|
|
|
Post by ASR (therockisback) on Feb 2, 2023 12:10:26 GMT -5
Foley is a real legend. I loved Cactus, Dude, Mankind & even his run as Mick Foley himself during 2000-today. I really wanted him to show up at RAW XXX the other week.
He’s one of the biggest stars & gave me too many classic memories.
|
|
|
Post by The Brain on Feb 2, 2023 14:38:58 GMT -5
Mankind brown attire> button up shirt and tie all day long
|
|
fabulous1971
Superstar
Derp!
Joined on: Apr 1, 2022 12:29:07 GMT -5
Posts: 509
|
Post by fabulous1971 on Feb 2, 2023 14:55:29 GMT -5
Mick Foley isn't on my Mount Rushmore, but I have a ton of respect for him and question any real pro wrestling fan who doesn't. I don't respect him one bit. So what question would you have that doesn't make me a "real pro wrestling" fan? Just because almost everyone likes him means that I have to? I don't care for his garbage death matches with Terry Funk in Japan. Garbage matches like that don't need any talent whatsoever. I don't care for his promos. They are nonsensical. From his cheap pops, and I don't care that's part of his gimmick, from him basically blowing himself every time he talks about himself. The HITC match was more garbage. It takes no talent at all to fall from very high places. What does that achieve? It just makes me think he was a moron for doing it. And I don't care. The whole going through the roof was planned and no matter what Bruce Prichard wants to say, there was a reason the cage had zip ties and when Taker choke slammed Foley he knew not to step on that piece. Ooooooh, he can fall onto thumb tacks, ooooooh he can take 12 chair shots to the head, ooooooh, splat on concrete, ooooooh fall through a table that's on fire. I'm not impressed. And I just think he's an bunghole. I was at the Sabu benefit show years ago and Foley was signing autographs and this little girl asked him if he could sign her arm, she had to be around 5 or 6. Foley just looked at her and said "only if you get 40 bucks from your parents". And no, that's not a lie or a fabrication, that's what he said. I mean come on, he couldn't just scribble anything for this little girl? She was very upset. And blah blah blah, good day, bad day, whatever. That right there made me not respect him the most. And don't give me the whole he doesn't owe anyone anything. That's my opinion on the guy, I'm not sorry if it's not the same opinion that others have.
|
|
|
Post by hbkbigdaddycool on Feb 2, 2023 15:01:33 GMT -5
Mick Foley the person, is kind of a complete douche though.
He preaches and talks about stuff like politics when the guy is a millionaire and never has to worry about money issues.
I feel his social media messages and tweets have made more fans hate him now than ever before.
Kevin Nash (who I am a huge fan of) and Batista also have the stigma about them. They are loaded with money and don't realize how the normal working man or woman lives so they feel they can bash things with how those people vote and what they believe in.
But overall, like I said in an earlier post, Cactus Jack of WCW and ECW was great. So was brown attire Mankind. Anything after that?? No thanks.
|
|
|
Post by ASR (therockisback) on Feb 2, 2023 15:02:23 GMT -5
I don't respect him one bit. So what question would you have that doesn't make me a "real pro wrestling" fan? Just because almost everyone likes him means that I have to? I don't care for his garbage death matches with Terry Funk in Japan. Garbage matches like that don't need any talent whatsoever. I don't care for his promos. They are nonsensical. From his cheap pops, and I don't care that's part of his gimmick, from him basically blowing himself every time he talks about himself. The HITC match was more garbage. It takes no talent at all to fall from very high places. What does that achieve? It just makes me think he was a moron for doing it. And I don't care. The whole going through the roof was planned and no matter what Bruce Prichard wants to say, there was a reason the cage had zip ties and when Taker choke slammed Foley he knew not to step on that piece. Ooooooh, he can fall onto thumb tacks, ooooooh he can take 12 chair shots to the head, ooooooh, splat on concrete, ooooooh fall through a table that's on fire. I'm not impressed. And I just think he's an bunghole. I was at the Sabu benefit show years ago and Foley was signing autographs and this little girl asked him if he could sign her arm, she had to be around 5 or 6. Foley just looked at her and said "only if you get 40 bucks from your parents". And no, that's not a lie or a fabrication, that's what he said. I mean come on, he couldn't just scribble anything for this little girl? She was very upset. And blah blah blah, good day, bad day, whatever. That right there made me not respect him the most. And don't give me the whole he doesn't owe anyone anything. That's my opinion on the guy, I'm not sorry if it's not the same opinion that others have. I respect your opinion & it sucks about the autograph signing.
|
|
jason1980s
Main Eventer
Joined on: Sept 30, 2009 14:58:56 GMT -5
Posts: 2,335
|
Post by jason1980s on Feb 2, 2023 15:20:05 GMT -5
I get it's pretty nasty to turn down a child but at autograph shows if he signs one freebie, every one will want one. And sometimes guys are bringing themselves in and whatever they make is what they take with them if promoters can't pay. A guy like Foley is most likely getting paid well before agreeing to appear but he's a smart man he knows signing that one freebie will bring on everyone else wanting one. I personally believe he was going through some issues maybe 10-15 years ago, there was a whole thread on another board dedicated to him being a dick at signings. I used to post it anytime someone said how awesome he was when they paid him their $15-40 at shows for that experience. I think the autograph signing Foley that Terry Funk alluded to in his book is the real Foley. You, the fan are simply money to him but I do feel as if he has gotten better over the last few years.
I personally agree with Fabulous1971 but not as harsh. Looking back now, his matches were something you don't want your kids or younger fans seeing. I feel like he did those insane bumps, chair shots etc...because he severely lacked the talent that many others had. I don't see him making it with the other guys of 1996-2000 era WWF talents if he hadn't done those insane bumps. He was/is bitter at Marc Mero for getting the guaranteed contract while he probably came in to WWF for much less. But it's based on WWF had to go on. Johnny B. Badd was a star the last few years in WCW while Foley lost a loser leaves town match to an over the hill guy who would go years without being on TV but literally would pop up on WCW simply because he was the booker. He had some awesome matches with Sting and Vader but other than that, he was normally a lower card extra.
I don't get the absolute love for him but also can't hate on him too much. I feel like he did what he did to provide for his wife and kids. And as for his daughter being offended that Taker didn't mention him in the HOF speech, Mick didn't make Taker, Taker made Mick.
|
|
|
Post by theoutlaw1999 on Feb 2, 2023 18:45:14 GMT -5
I get it's pretty nasty to turn down a child but at autograph shows if he signs one freebie, every one will want one. And sometimes guys are bringing themselves in and whatever they make is what they take with them if promoters can't pay. A guy like Foley is most likely getting paid well before agreeing to appear but he's a smart man he knows signing that one freebie will bring on everyone else wanting one. I personally believe he was going through some issues maybe 10-15 years ago, there was a whole thread on another board dedicated to him being a dick at signings. I used to post it anytime someone said how awesome he was when they paid him their $15-40 at shows for that experience. I think the autograph signing Foley that Terry Funk alluded to in his book is the real Foley. You, the fan are simply money to him but I do feel as if he has gotten better over the last few years. I personally agree with Fabulous1971 but not as harsh. Looking back now, his matches were something you don't want your kids or younger fans seeing. I feel like he did those insane bumps, chair shots etc...because he severely lacked the talent that many others had. I don't see him making it with the other guys of 1996-2000 era WWF talents if he hadn't done those insane bumps. He was/is bitter at Marc Mero for getting the guaranteed contract while he probably came in to WWF for much less. But it's based on WWF had to go on. Johnny B. Badd was a star the last few years in WCW while Foley lost a loser leaves town match to an over the hill guy who would go years without being on TV but literally would pop up on WCW simply because he was the booker. He had some awesome matches with Sting and Vader but other than that, he was normally a lower card extra. I don't get the absolute love for him but also can't hate on him too much. I feel like he did what he did to provide for his wife and kids. And as for his daughter being offended that Taker didn't mention him in the HOF speech, Mick didn't make Taker, Taker made Mick.Sorry I have to disagree there. This may be an unpopular opinion but Taker in the early 90's sucked. His matches were mediocre and the character was corny as hell. When Foley debut he helped evolve Taker, he gave a tired character a new lease of life and brought out a more darker side to him. The Mankind character was like a ultimate rival for him, he basically helped create The Phenom that we all remember fondly. Foley may not have made Taker, but he sure as hell helped bettered his character.
|
|
jason1980s
Main Eventer
Joined on: Sept 30, 2009 14:58:56 GMT -5
Posts: 2,335
|
Post by jason1980s on Feb 2, 2023 19:36:44 GMT -5
Foley may not have made Taker, but he sure as hell helped bettered his character. He did add a lot more for Taker than a lot of his previous opponents but much like his others, he and Mankind only feuded a few months before he moved on. The KOTR 98 was almost a makeshift feud. Like I think Mick was feuding with Steve Austin for some strange reason a PPV or two ago. His feuds with Mankind were about as long as Mabel, Giant Gonzalez and Kamala off the top of my head. And similar to Yoko as they feuded at other times. Taker did benefit from Foley being willing to do literally anything for the feud. I think I was premature in saying Taker made Mick because a lot of it was what Mick did working with so many different guys and being willing to destroy his body that made him famous. But without falling onto concrete floors, falling from far heights, exploding barb wire and thumb tacks, Jim Ross loving the guy and goofy pandering to the crowd jokes, I don't see him as anything special. With that being said, he is one heck of an author. At least the first two books. Not sure if he snuck anything perverse about Melina in another book. He ushered in a chance for anyone and everyone in wrestling to publish a book over the last 22 years. And unlike so many others he did the whole book himself, he didn't need a ghost writer. He is a super talented guy as an author, a great family man but as a wrestler I think he is what Flair said he is. Men and women in movies are probably doing far worse to their bodies than Foley did and have never and will never get the credit, fame or fortune that he has.
|
|
|
Post by theoutlaw1999 on Feb 2, 2023 21:26:18 GMT -5
Foley may not have made Taker, but he sure as hell helped bettered his character. He did add a lot more for Taker than a lot of his previous opponents but much like his others, he and Mankind only feuded a few months before he moved on. The KOTR 98 was almost a makeshift feud. Like I think Mick was feuding with Steve Austin for some strange reason a PPV or two ago. His feuds with Mankind were about as long as Mabel, Giant Gonzalez and Kamala off the top of my head. And similar to Yoko as they feuded at other times. Taker did benefit from Foley being willing to do literally anything for the feud. I think I was premature in saying Taker made Mick because a lot of it was what Mick did working with so many different guys and being willing to destroy his body that made him famous. But without falling onto concrete floors, falling from far heights, exploding barb wire and thumb tacks, Jim Ross loving the guy and goofy pandering to the crowd jokes, I don't see him as anything special. With that being said, he is one heck of an author. At least the first two books. Not sure if he snuck anything perverse about Melina in another book. He ushered in a chance for anyone and everyone in wrestling to publish a book over the last 22 years. And unlike so many others he did the whole book himself, he didn't need a ghost writer. He is a super talented guy as an author, a great family man but as a wrestler I think he is what Flair said he is. Men and women in movies are probably doing far worse to their bodies than Foley did and have never and will never get the credit, fame or fortune that he has. Absolutely, his and Taker's feud was short, but it gave Taker's character the kick it needed to evolve. He was never the best wrestler in the world but he was one of the best storytellers of all time. The live crowds ate up his matches and as a kid watching on the TV you could just feel his passion. Also Flair's opinion means jack all. At least Foley knew when to retire, Flair's still doesn't know when to hang up the boots. He may have been a better wrestler but when it comes to edge of the seat excitement and nail biting action, Foley beats Flair any day of the week.
|
|