|
Post by King Clayton of the MidWest on Sept 20, 2012 19:43:45 GMT -5
I wanted to get everyones choices between WWE, TNA, ROH.
Simply, who has it better..
-Best Wrestler in General
-Top Star
-Best Midcarder
-Best Angles
-Best Woman Wrestler
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.)
-Best Tag Teams
-Best Champions
-Best PPV
-Best Gimmicks
-Best Face
-Best Heel
-Best Young Talent
-The Company that has dead-weight
-Best Show
-Best Underrated Wrestler
-Overrated Wrestler
.........
Let me start...
Best Wrestler in General-CM Punk
Top Star-John Cena
Best Midcarder- Dolph Ziggler
Best Angles-TNA
Best Woman Wrestler-Eve
Best Women- TNA
Best Tag Teams-ROH
Best Champions-TNA
Best PPV-WWE
Best Gimmicks- TNA
Best Face-John Cena-WWE
Best Heel-Del Rio-WWE
Best Young Talent-Tie- ROH & TNA
The Company that has dead-weight-WWE
Best Show- RAW
Best Underrated Wrestler-Kevin Steen (Should be bigger)
Overrated Wrestler- Sheamus
|
|
|
Post by el torro on Sept 20, 2012 21:14:57 GMT -5
Best Wrestler in General: Dolph Ziggler
-Top Star: Sadly Cena
-Best Midcarder: Miz
-Best Angles: Hell No
-Best Woman Wrestler: Kaitlyn
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.): well, i already answered that.
-Best Tag Teams: D-Bry and Kane, again.
-Best Champions: D-Bry and Kane, Punk, Miz
-Best PPV: Extreme Rules 2012
-Best Gimmicks: Damien Sandow's
-Best Face: Christian (much more believable than ANYBODY)
-Best Heel: Too many to name.
-Best Young Talent: Drew McCintyre
-The Company that has dead-weight: what do you mean
-Best Show : Raw
-Best Underrated Wrestler: Jack Swagger
-Overrated Wrestler: Sheamus
|
|
|
Post by ultimateenigma on Sept 20, 2012 21:41:59 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General - CM Punk
-Top Star - John Cena
-Best Midcarder - Ryback
-Best Angles- TNA
-Best Woman Wrestler - Eve
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) - Knockouts
-Best Tag Teams- TNA
-Best Champions- TNA
-Best PPV- TNA and WWE tied
-Best Gimmicks- TNA
-Best Face- John Cena
-Best Heel - without a doubt, Bully Ray
-Best Young Talent - Brutus Magnus
-The Company that has dead-weight - WWE
-Best Show - TNA
-Best Underrated Wrestler - Samoa Joe
-Overrated Wrestler - Austin Aries
|
|
|
Post by JC Motors on Sept 20, 2012 21:43:00 GMT -5
WWE
|
|
|
Post by el torro on Sept 20, 2012 22:24:41 GMT -5
OHOHOHOH! We're comparing WWE to TNA and ROH! I getchaa. I thought it was just within WWE. well, I'm too lazy to start over.
|
|
davemartini1127
Mid-Carder
Joined on: Sept 6, 2010 17:56:35 GMT -5
Posts: 67
|
Post by davemartini1127 on Sept 21, 2012 0:22:05 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General: Daniel Bryan
-Top Star: John Cena
-Best Midcarder: Cody Rhodes
-Best Angles: WWE
-Best Woman Wrestler: Beth
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.): WWE
-Best Tag Teams: WWE
-Best Champions: WWE
-Best PPV: TNA
-Best Gimmicks: TNA
-Best Face: Austin Aries, Christian(Tied, because both are great babyfaces)
-Best Heel: Daniel Bryan, Bully Ray, Kevin Steen(Tied because their the only real heels that make me care about them)
-Best Young Talent: WWE(Nearly all of the NXT season 1, Ceasaro)
-The Company that has dead-weight: TNA(RoH if the gutcheck doesn't count)
-Best Show: TNA iMPACT
-Best Underrated Wrestler: Rhett Titus, Darren Young, and Sonjay Dutt
-Overrated Wrestler: Davey Richards, Dolph Ziggler, and Mr. Anderson
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Jun 9, 2024 5:41:28 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 21, 2012 0:36:14 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General CM Punk. He's really the only thing keeping me interested in WWE at the moment besides Kane and Bryan. His promos and matches are always entertaining, and he brings out the best of Cena.
-Top Star John Cena. It's painfully obvious, whether anyone wants to admit it or not.
-Best Midcarder The Miz. I think he's excellent.
-Best Angles Aces and Eights. Nothing else really stands out to me except that. It's starting to drag on and get old to me though, they need to change it up.
-Best Woman Wrestler Tara. I've always found her to be very underrated. Not to mention, best ass in the business.
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) Knockouts
-Best Tag Teams Tie for me. I love Daniels and Kazarian and AJ Styles and Kurt Angle in TNA, but I also really like Kane and Bryan as well as the Prime Time Players in WWE.
-Best Champions Another tie for me between WWE and TNA.
-Best PPV Night of Champions 2012. A very solid show.
-Best Gimmicks TNA
-Best Face Austin Aries & Jeff Hardy
-Best Heel Bully Ray. He's the best heel I've seen on either show in a long time.
-Best Young Talent Zack Ryder, Antonio Cesaro, Seth Rollins, and Kassis Ohno.
-The Company that has dead-weight WWE
-Best Show Impact Wrestling, no doubt.
-Best Underrated Wrestler Michael McGillicutty
-Overrated Wrestler Cody Rhodes and Alberto Del Rio
|
|
|
Post by Thick Justice on Sept 21, 2012 1:53:25 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General: WWE Daniel Bryan
-Top Star- WWE- they have the top stair in wrestling in Cena even if I don't like him as a wrestler
-Best Midcarder - WWE as TNA doesn't really have a midcard and I can't think of any great midcarder in ROH. Not sure who I'd say is best in WWE but they got a lot of guys that are in midcard and undercard that could be world champ right now if they were to have left to TNA a year ago.
-Best Angles- Currently TNA
-Best Woman Wrestler- TNA they have better ones then WWE and there the only company I can say that has a great woman's wrestler and a division. I'd say if Sara Del Rey was in TNA right now she'd get it. However I can't give it to ROH when they only have 3 woman and only 1 is a full time wrestler.
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) Knockouts for sure especially if Phoenix jumps ship or retires.
-Best Tag Teams- ROH there division might be lacking right now but theres still beats out wwe's.
-Best Champions- WWE atleast until TNA crowns a new TV champion. Lets hope its someone that is a better opponent then a 9 year old girl or a blow up doll. You can't tell me that devon is better then them.
-Best PPV- I guess I'd go with TNA and have it be Lockdown or BFG
-Best Gimmicks- I guess I'll have to be honest. WWE sucks at coming up with there gimmicks. TNA is hit or miss. ROH doesn't really have gimmicks they come up with.
-Best Face- ROH doesn't have a top face. TNA has Aries who is coming off heelish lately. WWE has John Cena. I sadly go with WWE. As a top face he does his business standpoint better then anyone of the past decade in any company.
-Best Heel- TNA Aces and 8's
-Best Young Talent- WWE
-The Company that has dead-weight- TNA- still a lot of dead weight
-Best Show- TNA
-Best Underrated Wrestler- WWE- R-Truth- He should stay face but they need to turn little Jimmy heel. Then that drives R-Truth crazier getting tripped by little jimmy. It'd be funny. Eventually leading to R-Truth being institutionalized by Kofi to get him help. He comes back and says Lil Jimmy's okay now and so is he. Then first chance he gets he attacks Kofi during a match. He goes on a rampage attacking his former friends and says while he was locked up Little Jimmy was the only one who came to visit. He says he's listening to little Jimmy now. He becomes totally unstable and they even have an angle where he attacks a fan with an anti Jimmy sign. Cut the tv and everything. By now a heel is running Smackdown and he brings over R-truth and little Jimmy and makes them his top heel ala Eric B. and HHH. Give R-Truth a long run as champion then have him lose it to someone and la dee dah etc. etc.
-Overrated Wrestler- Cena
|
|
|
Post by Calcifer Boheme on Sept 21, 2012 2:31:42 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General- Punk
-Top Star- Cena
-Best Midcarder- Dolph
-Best Angles- All three have things I like and things I don't.
-Best Woman Wrestler- Sara Del Ray
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.)- Divas. TNA has lost too many of their quality females. Also, I'm including NXT divas and the fact that WWE signed Del Ray
-Best Tag Teams- ROH, though WWE could easily catch up if they actually pushed the division and used the teams they have on NXT
-Best Champions-
-Best PPV- WWE
-Best Gimmicks- WWE
-Best Face- Cena
-Best Heel- Bully Ray
-Best Young Talent- Counting NXT, WWE wins. Not counting NXT, ROH does
-The Company that has dead-weight- WWE would have to win this one, they have the most workers over all, the law of averages is against them
-Best Show- NXT
-Best Underrated Wrestler- I don't like doing under/over rated
-Overrated Wrestler
|
|
|
Post by punksnotdead on Sept 21, 2012 8:07:40 GMT -5
Best Wrestler in General: Austin Aries or Bobby Roode I give it to TNA either way
Top Star: WWE with CM Punk & John Cena
Best Midcarder: Dolph Ziggler
Best Angles: TNA sans the AJ baby thing
Best Woman Wrestler: Madison Rayne
Best Women: TNA
Best Tag Teams: I would have said ROH before ANX ended with KK's departure, now it's pretty even between all 3 imo. WWE has the edge if we count NXT.
Best Champions: This is a tough comparison. I'd say WWE here as a whole. Cesaro, Miz, Punk, Bryan & Kane. Only guy I don't like as champion is Sheamus and he's just keeping it warm for my favorite guy on WWE's roster.
Best PPV: WrestleMania but I think TNA consistently has better PPVs
Best Gimmicks: TNA
Best Face: Austin Aries
Best Heel: Bobby Roode or Bully Ray
Best Young Talent: Overall? WWE since NXT is loaded with talent imo. Plus, young ROH talent gets cherry picked now days anyway. Expect Adam Cole and Eddie Edwards to be in TNA or WWE in the not too distant future.
The Company that has dead-weight: I guess WWE by default? Just because they can afford to pay guys they don't use or that have been driven into the ground, like Big Show imo.
Best Show: Impact
Best Underrated Wrestler: That's tough. I'd probably go with Kenny King or Kassius Ohno in terms of how they are being used. I love Ohno's NXT promos and the whole gimmick.
Overrated Wrestler: Sheamus imo
|
|
|
Post by marino13 on Sept 21, 2012 8:35:12 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General Daniel Bryan
-Top Star Cena
-Best Midcarder Christian
-Best Angles Kane & Bryan (Aces & 8's a close second)
-Best Woman Wrestler Beth Phoenix or Tara
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) At one time I'd have said TNA but now both are mediocre
-Best Tag Teams Both are weak, but WWE seems to be on the right path.
-Best Champions WWE has more to choose from, while TNA has the TV & Knockout Tag just laying around.
-Best PPV Wrestlemania, though I thought NOC was fantastic.
-Best Gimmicks Gimmicks are few and far between, but I'll take Kane over Abyss.
-Best Face Cena
-Best Heel Robert Roode
-Best Young Talent WWE has Drew, Kofi, Rhodes, & Ziggler.
-The Company that has dead-weight Both
-Best Show this answer changes weekly
-Best Underrated Wrestler Drew McIntyre
-Overrated Wrestler Abyss
|
|
|
Post by pxkgotosleep on Sept 21, 2012 8:39:13 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General CM Punk. He's really the only thing keeping me interested in WWE at the moment besides Kane and Bryan. His promos and matches are always entertaining, and he brings out the best of Cena. -Best Angles Aces and Eights. Nothing else really stands out to me except that. It's starting to drag on and get old to me though, they need to change it up. -Best Woman Wrestler Tara. I've always found her to be very underrated. Not to mention, best ass in the business. -Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) Knockouts -Best Tag Teams Tie for me. I love Daniels and Kazarian and AJ Styles and Kurt Angle in TNA, but I also really like Kane and Bryan as well as the Prime Time Players in WWE. -Best Champions Another tie for me between WWE and TNA. -Best PPV Slammiversary 2012. -Best Gimmicks TNA -Best Face Austin Aries & Jeff Hardy -Best Heel Bully Ray. He's the best heel I've seen on either show in a long time. -Best Young Talent Antonio Cesaro, Seth Rollins, and Kassis Ohno. -The Company that has dead-weight WWE -Best Show Impact Wrestling, no doubt. -Best Underrated Wrestler Tensai-Overrated Wrestler Cody Rhodes and Alberto Del Rio This, essentially.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Jun 9, 2024 5:41:28 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 21, 2012 10:39:25 GMT -5
-Best Underrated Wrestler TensaiWin. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -Best Wrestler in General: Christian-Top Star: John Cena-Best Midcarder: Tensai -Best Angles: Cena/Punk-Best Woman Wrestler: They're all bad.-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.): Aksana (going by looks)-Best Tag Teams - Prime Time Players-Best Champions - Sheamus-Best PPV - Wrestlemania 28-Best Gimmicks - Tensai-Best Face - Sheamus-Best Heel - Tensai-Best Young Talent - Dolph Ziggler-The Company that has dead-weight - TNA (they have a Dudley Boy), WWE (they have Wade Barrett & The Miz)-Best Show - RAW-Best Underrated Wrestler - Tensai-Overrated Wrestler - Wade Barrett
|
|
ohernan6
Main Eventer
'Cause That's How I Roll!
Joined on: Jan 20, 2009 17:40:44 GMT -5
Posts: 1,670
|
Post by ohernan6 on Sept 21, 2012 12:14:53 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General KURT ANGLE
-Top Star UNDERTAKER.... JUST KIDDING, IT HAS TO BE JOHN CENA
-Best Midcarder CHRISTIAN
-Best Angles WWE - PARTICULARLY CM PUNK'S STORYLINES
-Best Woman Wrestler TARA
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) DIVAS
-Best Tag Teams WWE - I LIKE WATCHING THE COLONS, PRIMETIME PLAYERS, AND REY & SIN CARA
-Best Champions TNA - THEY TREAT THEIR WORLD CHAMPION WITH RESPECT
-Best PPV I HAVEN'T WATCHED ANY THIS YEAR, BUT IM GUESSING WWE, ESPECIALLY WITH LESNAR'S INVOLVEMENT
-Best Gimmicks WWE
-Best Face REY MYSTERIO
-Best Heel ROBERT ROODE
-Best Young Talent WWE
-The Company that has dead-weight WWE
-Best Show THIS ONE IS TOUGH - TIE BETWEEN RAW AND IMPACT
-Best Underrated Wrestler CHRISTIAN
-Overrated Wrestler JOHN CENA
|
|
noir
Main Eventer
Joined on: May 20, 2007 6:53:47 GMT -5
Posts: 4,278
|
Post by noir on Sept 21, 2012 12:38:53 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General CM Punk -Top Star CM Punk -Best Midcarder Damien Sandow -Best Angles TNA -Best Woman Wrestler Paige from NXT because I'd do terrible things to her -Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) Knockouts -Best Tag Teams TNA -Best Champions WWE -Best PPV WWE's have been weak since OTL imo, but Night Of Champions was best PPV in a couple of months so that -Best Gimmicks WWE -Best Face Jeff Hardy -Best Heel Paul Heyman atm -Best Young Talent Cesaro, Ziggler, Sandow -The Company that has dead-weight WWE -Best Show impact -Best Underrated Wrestler Christopher Daniels, and he has been for several years. Jimmy Jacobs close second. -Overrated Wrestler Tyler Black/ Henry Rollins
(haven't watched ROH in a couple of years, no idea what's going on there atm.)
TNA has better product at the moment though, fer sure.
|
|
Falconsinclair
Superstar
Joined on: Jun 24, 2012 9:16:24 GMT -5
Posts: 803
|
Post by Falconsinclair on Sept 21, 2012 13:58:06 GMT -5
Before I start I have to include Chikara for a few categories
Best Wrestler in General TIE CM Punk & Daniel Bryan
Top Star The Rock even though he's part time he is still the biggest draw in the business right now
Best Midcarder Zack Ryder
Best Angles Chikara - their slow build up really helps this promotion out
Best Woman Wrestler Sara Del Ray - She is under WWE Development
Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) WWE - TNA is dropping the Knockouts like flies lately, which buts the WWE Divas slightly above them right now TNA at the moment is only focusing on 3-4 women right now
Best Tag Teams Once again I have to go with Chikara - the fed is primarily based around tag teams and stables
Best Champions Overall WWE, their titles are way more prestigious then anything ROH & TNA have
Best PPV WWE WrestleMania - pretty much any given year this is THE event that most wrestlers strive to make it on.
Best Gimmicks Chikara once again. I am really loving the gimmicks their roster is populated with
Best Face John Cena - with the WWE hype machine behind him I can't see anyone taking him out of this spot especially when it comes to his charity work
Best Heel CM Punk - When he's a heel he is gold, when he's a face he starts to get lost in the shuffle
Best Young Talent WWE - When you have Tyler Black (Seth Rollins), Chris Hero (Kassius Ohno), Richie Steamboat & Michael McGillicutty all in development your doing something ring
The Company that has dead-weight WWE - Their roster could use a lot of trimming right now, especially since they only seem to focus on 20 guys or so at a time.
Best Show Monday Night Raw - still the place that most wrestlers want to appear on on a regular basis
Best Underrated Wrestler Antonio Cesaro - if they drop Aksana and let him do more then say one word in 5 different languages he can be gold
Overrated Wrestler Kevin Steen - Not sure what all the hype about him is, and seeing as I've seen him live in Ontario I still don't get it.
|
|
|
Post by Rule 30 on Sept 21, 2012 14:29:51 GMT -5
In a nutshell, TNA has the best wrestling, but I think outside of the big storylines (Aces and Eights, Storm/Roode, and Aries/Hardy) WWE has the best angles.
|
|
|
Post by adzy on Sept 21, 2012 17:48:47 GMT -5
Best Angle- Kurt
|
|
|
Post by xtremeperil on Sept 21, 2012 18:28:19 GMT -5
With the exception of Nights Of Champions, I haven't seen much wrestling since College started. Best Wrestler in General ~ CM Punk. Not the biggest fan of the character direction, but when it comes to in between the ropes, I still think he's the Best In The World. Runner up is Dolph Ziggler. Top Star ~ John Cena. A little birdie told me this guy is something of a success. Best Midcarder ~ The Miz. An alternate title for this award is "Best As A Midcarder And Should Never Ever Ne Anywhere Near The Main Event Again Unless Nobody Else Is Available But In That Circumstance Should Only Be Used As Fodder For The Champion". Best Angles ~ I'm not following TNA or ROH, so WWE by default.Best Woman Wrestler ~ Eve Torres. She's also the most attractive. She wins both easily. Runner up is Mickie James. Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.) ~ Diva's. That said, it seems TNA uses the Knockouts better than WWE uses the Diva's, so it was close. Best Tag Teams ~ Hell No! . . . Has no idea if that's their official tag name or not. Best Champions ~ WWE. CM Punk, Eve, Daniel Bryan, Kane are all awesome. Miz and Sheamus are good too. And while I don't care for Cesaro, he's a thousand times better than Santino. As for TNA; Austin Aries is awesome . . . Kaz & Daniels are awesome but I don't like them as a team. Devon is terrible, Tessmacher is a poor as a wrestler. Oh, and why the is Eric Young one half of the Knockouts Tag Team Champion!? Best PPV ~ Extreme Rules probably. If I didn't miss the tag match or the WHC match at Night Of Champions, that might've won it. Best Gimmicks ~ ROH. Because I'm fairly with the stupid gimmicks TNA and WWE have provided us. ROH I have no idea so it can't piss me off. Best Face ~ I don't know, Cena? Best Heel ~ Paul Heyman. No explanation needed. Best Young Talent ~ Dolph ZigglerThe Company that has dead-weight ~ All of them probably. What? You didn't specify "the most" or "the least"? Okay fine, WWE probably edges it out for the victory. Best Show ~ Don't know. Only watch clips of Raw online and can't say I've particularly enjoyed what I've seen. Ignoring the last two because I can't decide whether or not to do by how the company rates them or the IWC.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Jun 9, 2024 5:41:28 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 21, 2012 21:33:37 GMT -5
-Best Wrestler in General; jeff hardy
-Top Star; john cena
-Best Midcarder; cody rhodes
-Best Angles; wwe
-Best Woman Wrestler; aj and eve
-Best Women (Divas or Knockouts.): wwe
-Best Tag Teams: wwe
-Best Champions: wwe
-Best PPV: wwe
-Best Gimmicks: wwe
-Best Face: john cena
-Best Heel: daniel bryan and cm punk
-Best Young Talent: tna
-The Company that has dead-weight: wwe
-Best Show: raw
-Best Underrated Wrestler: tensai
-Overrated Wrestler: john cena
|
|