Ross
Main Eventer
Joined on: Nov 21, 2008 9:43:29 GMT -5
Posts: 3,154
|
Post by Ross on Apr 20, 2013 14:10:47 GMT -5
"WELCOME TO ANIMANIA XI" "Lets kick of Animania with a Australia Vs. America for the Euro title... Ok then." European Championship:Josh (c) Vs. asmi5065 -Stip: Superplex from the apron into ring whilst standing on the middle rope. Josh: i.minus.com/ibirBCyO2bey43.gifasmi5065: How to vote on matches: No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following: 1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?) 2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended) If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions. Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match. VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 14:19:13 GMT -5
Looks like a good opener for Mania.
Josh: Nice ani here, overall smooth for the majority of the animation, not that stiff, good airtime, impact, and reaction. My main problems with this ani were the bit of slidyness from Orton and Ziggler after impact, and there being a few pics lacking in Ziggler's bounce. Overall nice ani.
ASMI: Nice ani here, looks like you stepped up your game a bit. The superkick was a bit slow, but smooth and not stiff. I loved that you added the climbing of the ropes, even though you have a weird as hell ring with little space inbetween ropes. ;P The pause was perfect length, the suplex had good airtime but looked like it lacked some frames. The impact was nice, but Cara's bounce was way too high(4/20) and unrealistic, but nice reactions.
Both anis are good, but I'm voting Asmi because of his animation having good build up and even though the impact was unrealistic, I thought it looked better than Josh's.
|
|
|
Post by Andeh on Apr 20, 2013 14:19:31 GMT -5
Great match to get Mania started. I thought both animations where fantastic.
Josh's was a extremely smooth however it needed to be sped up. Was a little slow in my opinion. Had great impact and general movement. I think a rope bounce would have added to it but overall a fantastic animation.
Asmis was great aswell. I liked how you included him climbing the ropes. Was smooth and had great movement also. However I thought the impact was over the top. Cara really bounced. I thought the reaction was good but the overall impact sort of killed the animation for me.
Both did fantastic and a great showing but Josh gets my vote.
|
|
Dan.
Main Eventer
Joined on: May 5, 2009 12:46:28 GMT -5
Posts: 1,989
|
Post by Dan. on Apr 20, 2013 14:21:03 GMT -5
Nice match guys, and good work making this awkward stip.
I'm voting for Josh.
asmi: your animation was good. I like the build up, and the step up onto the 2nd rope was a really good touch and it was really well done too. I think the pause was slightly too long, but the move itself was fine. I understand it's difficult with both figures being in the air, but bourne seemed to fall awkwardly, and sin cara's oversell was a bit over the top. The whole thing flowed really well though, but it might have been a touch too slow. Nice work though.
Josh: Easily my favourite animation you've made. It was a shame there was no build up at all, orton just started on the ropes, but the lift was well done, i mean, ziggler was a little stiff but there's not many ways you can move someone in a suplex. orton's movements during the move were fantastic, and the whole move just seemed really well timed. I felt zigglers bounce was a little awkward, but when he moved to hold his back, that was awesome. Because of the nature of your animation style, the whole thing had a great flow and was the right speed, but the end seemed little fidgety, orton in particular, but zigglers leg movements at the end were a little messy too. That doesn't detract too much from a truly great animation. Awesome stuff. Keep it up.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 14:21:52 GMT -5
Josh: I liked the set up, the pick up was great but I thought both figures were stiff in mid air. The animation flowed smoothly and did not seem fidgety in any part. The impact and the reaction were very nice. Other than that, nothing much to say here.
Asmi: The animation was good, i liked how you tried to include some sequence before the move. Evan was a little choppy while climbing the rope. Same as Josh, the suplex was kinda stiff, but i guess it's suppose to be like that, just like the real movements. The impact wasn't so great, but i liked how you tried to make Sin Cara oversell..
Vote: Josh
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 14:28:11 GMT -5
Nice Opener.
Josh - Good Job. Overall smoothness was really here in this animation. I felt Dolph's legs were a tad stiff, I also felt that the several camera angle changes hindered your animation slightly. I felt Dolph and Orton were quite slidy after impact which let you down, but I liked the joint movement by Orton. I also thought part of Zigglers reaction missed a few frames for me.
Asmi - Nice Job. Superkick was a bit slow however, it actually was pretty smooth. I liked the effort you made to have bourne climb the ropes which was good. Nice airtime to the suplex, good speed if anything a tad choppy in places but nothing to bad, Sin Cara's reaction was pretty unrealistic I felt but it was pretty smooth and I liked the flow and the reactions of the ani.
I am going to vote ASMI here. Reason : I really liked his build up and although I felt some of it lacked a few frames, i thought in general it looked better and had a better flow than Josh's.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 14:30:49 GMT -5
Vote- Josh Asmi: Your animation was pretty good I just think that the speed was a little to slow. Also it seemed that it was choppy and decently stiff at the start.
Josh: Orton did have some fidgets at the end but I still liked the ani. It had a smoothness Asmi's animation didnt have and the joint movement was overall better.
Good match guys
|
|
JDP
Main Eventer
WFigs biggest Justin Gabriel fan.
Joined on: Aug 22, 2012 2:09:11 GMT -5
Posts: 3,561
|
Post by JDP on Apr 20, 2013 14:31:53 GMT -5
Very close, and a great match. Just by the shed of a cat, ASMI gets my vote.
I thought ASMI had pretty good build up with the superkick and the positioning onto the middle rope. I thought his animation was really smooth throughout the animation, the speed helped it alot. Also the reaction from Cara was well done.
Josh, your animation was not your best to be honest. I thought it was really smooth as always but it seemed to be a bit slow which was one of the main things that put you down in this match. I felt in the suplex that ziggler was a bit stiff, in the reaction the camera angle change kind of interupted it. The reaction also seemed unfinished.
Awesome match.
|
|
|
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Apr 20, 2013 14:32:36 GMT -5
My vote goes to Asmi5065 on this one.
Josh: Very nice animation you have here Josh. At the beginning I really didn't like the lack of build-up to show how they got on the ropes in that position, it wasn't very realistic and it didn't balance out the ani very well. The suplex was very nicely done, it was smooth, it had great mid air and neither Dolph nor Randy Orton looked stiff throughout the motion. I think it could have been a bit faster but the reaction's from both really needs some work. 8.5/10
Asmi5065: A fine animation you have here Asmi. At the start I really like how you included a build-up to make the animation flow better and make it look more realistic. The superkick was very smooth and Evan Bourne didn't look very stiff but maybe a few frames here and there evened out the movements a tad better, the reaction from Sin Cara wasn't that bad imo. The climbing onto the middle rope looked quite awkward and fidgety which took away from the quality of the animation. The suplex wasn't bad but Sin Cara looked a little bit stiff in mid air. The impact was good and I really like the reaction at the end. 8.6/10
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 14:48:03 GMT -5
I vote for ASMI. Although Josh's was smoother, I liked ASMI's because of the build up and the over-the-top-ish reaction along with the impact. Nice match guys!
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 15:37:37 GMT -5
Wow! All I can say is wow! What a way to kick off animania!
Both were great but my vote has to go with Josh!
Asmi5065: your animation was good but i could see some shadows at the start which Josh didn't have! Also Josh had a better Camera Quality and a better Camera angle! There was a few things that i saw in Asmi5065's animation that Josh didn't have like the build up in Asmi's animation it had the Superkick then the Suplex! But on Josh's Animation the video just seemed to start when Orton and Ziggler were up on the ropes! But one thing that I noticed was that on Josh's Animation when it switched camera positions at first Orton's body was only a few millimetres away but when the Camera switched angle Orton was sitting up! Which on Azmi's Evans back looked like it got injured a little and it didn't give a big jump! But the main reasons that my vote goes to Josh is because of the Smoothment and the Lighting! On Azmi's the figures looked a little blurry and it seemed to be quite dark! Yet on Josh's Ani it was about the right brightness for animations and it looked very clear with the correct lighting! But Smoothment is a very big thing! If just Azmi took a few more pictures it would look very smooth and could of possibly earned my vote! Anyway this was a very hard decision and it looked like both of them put a lot of effort into it!!!
|
|
|
Post by wwextreme25 on Apr 20, 2013 17:26:19 GMT -5
Contender for MOTN surely? i mean, ASMI you really brought everything to the table here bro great job!
Josh: Really nice ani here man i loved the flow of it especially and thought it was really smooth. The lift up flowed really nicely and was extremely smooth and i especially loved the way you had orton move his feet off the ropes as he fell - didnt look stiff and looked very effective but i thought zigglers legs were a little stiff but not too much. The thing that ruined the ani was the second camera angle - not the angle itself but the animation within the second camera angle (if that makes sense). Ortons movements were ok - very smooth but there shouldve been more to it than him just sitting up. I saw string though which was kinda annoying to see - dolphs reaction was ok but wasnt great. The two camera angles ruined it at the secod half of the ani - you shouldve only used one. good effort though 7.7/10
ASMI: Completely didnt expect this from you. The animation was great.! Start of the animation was a little bit fidgety from cara and the ring moved a bit too so it looked a bit weird. Liked how you added a superkick but caras reaction was kinda choppy from it. The walk up the ropes was great but a slightest bit fidgety. The suplex imo was better than josh's cause it had better flow and the oversell was incredible however the shadow's kinda were annoying. 7.5/10
Vote: JOSH because although ASMI brought everything to the table, i found more fault in the animation than josh's as josh's had a cleaner outcome. Really nice job though asmi be proud of that ani.
|
|
Leones
Mid-Carder
Nobody can touch me.
Joined on: May 27, 2012 15:44:06 GMT -5
Posts: 332
|
Post by Leones on Apr 20, 2013 19:39:19 GMT -5
ASMI: Apreciate a lot that you did the whole build up. The whole animation itself was a lot choppy and lacked frames here and there, so it broke a bit with the smoothness it would have... The suplex was good, but the reaction from Sin Cara was a bit unrealistic as he went so high. Good job from you overall!
Josh: Super smooth, quality and good joint movements too. The whole thing flowed correctly, like it should, although would be better if you did the build up like asmi. Could've edited the string, but not a big deal. The reactions were good, nice job!
My vote goes to JOSH.
|
|
|
Post by [The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk on Apr 21, 2013 1:15:18 GMT -5
Josh : i always liked your camera quality, and your smoothness, which is indeed there in this animation, there was no build-up which is kinda bad, the move itself was good but kinda stiff, i mean suplexes are stiff but you can make them look not as stiff, i like how Orton didn't go far away while delivering the move, i saw some strings but not too much, reaction was good, but during the angle change Orton kinda changed place.
ASMI: Nice way to debut your mattel animation - do it at AniMania haha! The superkick was good but i would like a little jump, nice reaction to kick by Cara, i really like how Evan climbs the ropes, kinda fidgety but a good build-up, the move was a bit choppier than Josh's, but i think that joints were moved better for both figures, the reaction was kinda cool but maybe if cara was a bit lower than it would be even better.
Vote : ASMI, overall because of a good build-up and a better, more real like flow of move, with joints moved etc.
|
|
extreme2213
Jobber
Oh Really?
Joined on: Feb 1, 2010 3:11:34 GMT -5
Posts: 46
|
Post by extreme2213 on Apr 21, 2013 1:33:51 GMT -5
My vote goes to Josh
It was smoother, the impact was a tiny bit better. Although some string was visible, it still look a lot better.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 3:11:34 GMT -5
Whoa! a Close match right there
Josh : Really Nice ani right there ,great Camera quality ,Reaction was abit off at the end though ,ani was great needed a bit more pics ,kinda stiff but flowed smooth and pretty well. - 8/10
Asmi : Really great ani there ,appreciate you making the build up and rope climb ,the Suplex was a bit stiff but really nice ,reaction was a bit not realistic though :/ - 7.9/10
Vote : Josh.
|
|
GAm3r357
Mid-Carder
Los Matadores.
Joined on: May 5, 2012 6:57:08 GMT -5
Posts: 111
|
Post by GAm3r357 on Apr 21, 2013 6:11:27 GMT -5
wow unbelievable match guys.
JOsh: I loved the smoothness and flow to this animation however it didnt look that realistic to me, The flow was nice, as i said, and the joint movement coming off the ropes was great but the impact wasnt there for me and the two camera angles at the end were uneeded and seemed unrealistic which ruined the ani. i also saw string so that was another factor in the animation.
Asmi: Really loved this ani from you. There were a few points where it was fidgety such as having bourne climb the ropes but i loved how you added that in. superkick was nice but a little stiff however, thats not the stip im concentrating on...its the suplex. mid air movements were really nice and i loved the effort you put in - especially on the reaction. People may say its unrealistic, but look at rock oversell a stunner...thats unrealistic for real life but he does it for effect, same way you did here so i think it was a great reaction. Overall the animation was nice.
Vote: Asmi - animation had more realism and a better impact/reaction.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 6:04:14 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 10:05:50 GMT -5
This one is really difficult for me.
Josh`s was very smooth and flowed well throughout. I figure these guys may have difficulty with fidgettyness on this one but they didnt. What I like about Josh`s is that it really looked like a standard suplex which doesnt seem like much but I think it`s worth noting that he got the realism factor down well. The slight leg movements by Orton really added to the animation in my view. The only thing I didnt like was the impact as Orton shifted a little. I think you did that on purpose and it wasnt really a mistake but I dont think it came out well. Zigglers reaction was realistic and animated well.
Asmi`s wasnt as smooth but I could tell there was more effort put into the move. The superkick was alright, I don`t like how Bournes arms stayed in the same place. The fact that you attempted having a rope climb was great, even if it wasnt perfect. The suplex was great, there were a few frames I didnt like before the fall but overall I like how you made it a little different and therefore had a different reaction based on the purposely awkward fall. The reaction was overdone but fun to watch.
When I can`t decide, I pick creativity over smoothness. Vote: Asmi
|
|
Ben
Mid-Carder
Joined on: Dec 12, 2012 22:07:00 GMT -5
Posts: 54
|
Post by Ben on Apr 21, 2013 10:18:39 GMT -5
ASMI5065: Great animation from you I really liked it. I thought the animation was stiff, sorry. Still pretty smooth but at one part I feel as though you didn't take enough pics.
Josh: Really liked the animation, great joint movement it flowed very well and not at all stiff. Very good although I saw string for a couple of
|
|
Ben
Mid-Carder
Joined on: Dec 12, 2012 22:07:00 GMT -5
Posts: 54
|
Post by Ben on Apr 21, 2013 10:20:33 GMT -5
ASMI5065: Great animation from you I really liked it. I thought the animation was stiff, sorry. Still pretty smooth but at one part I feel as though you didn't take enough pics. 7/10
Josh: Really liked the animation, great joint movement it flowed very well and not at all stiff. Very good although I saw string for a couple of frames. 9/10
Vote Josh. (Remove my other comment.)
|
|