Ross
Main Eventer
Joined on: Nov 21, 2008 9:43:29 GMT -5
Posts: 3,154
|
Post by Ross on Apr 20, 2013 16:08:41 GMT -5
"Who will be Mr. MITB?" Money in the bankArrow Vs. Andeh Vs. DANiel Vs. Rob Vs. Skits Vs. #Showoff -Stip: Create a sequence ending in any move off a ladder. Arrow: Andeh: DANiel: img254.imageshack.us/img254/5444/mitb4.gifRob: Skits: i45.tinypic.com/281rioy.jpg#Showoff: i.minus.com/itpBiUiKaVmBb.gifHow to vote on matches: No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following: 1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?) 2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended) If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions. Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match. VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS
|
|
Dan.
Main Eventer
Joined on: May 5, 2009 12:46:28 GMT -5
Posts: 1,989
|
Post by Dan. on Apr 20, 2013 16:28:54 GMT -5
holy sh**
good luck everyone.
|
|
Leones
Mid-Carder
Nobody can touch me.
Joined on: May 27, 2012 15:44:06 GMT -5
Posts: 332
|
Post by Leones on Apr 20, 2013 20:00:11 GMT -5
It came down to Rob and Arrow, so I'm only commenting for this two. Arrow: Really liked the sequence of finishers, all went smooth, with the right flow, so realistic. I think you should edit the string in your animations because it is very noticeable, and they will look even more realistic and better as you may know I would like to see more moves involving ladders, but is ok. I think the move you did, the super powerbomb from the ladder was superb, very well done on that and I really liked the Jomo's reactions, pretty well done, so I don't know what to say more, I really liked, very well done! Rob: One of your best animation of all time for me, that was fantastic... I love how you move 4 or 5 figures at the same time, and even how you move two different spots in the air, when Sin Cara is jumping for the springboard and Tyson is doing the german suplex, just unbelieveble. Everything went really smooth as always, I can't see any string, and every single move had that feeling, that realism feeling, idk, that really nice touch. At the last spot I would like and I think it would make the animation even better, you should've made the C4 from Sin Cara instead of the hurricarana, but that's just my opinion And I think Sin Cara going so far out of the ring was a bit unrealistic, and no needed, but anyway. Superb job! My vote goes to Rob.
|
|
ace
Superstar
Joined on: Sept 28, 2012 19:36:47 GMT -5
Posts: 906
|
Post by ace on Apr 20, 2013 20:18:41 GMT -5
Wow very hard match to vote on. Some very good animations here.
But, it all boils down to Arrow, Rob, and, Skits for me.
Skits: Nice animation. Very smooth and good moves but really stiff. Like when Shawn was walking he never picked up his feet which looked very unrealistic and when Cena was falling down he barely moved. If you moved the joints more it would probably be the best one though.
Rob: Really awesome job man! Super smooth and super hard moves like the ending C4 of the ladders was flawless. Like Leones said its just amazing how you can do two moves with string at once! Very nice animation dude seemed almost impossible to make and definitely your best in my opinion.
Arrow: Amazing job! This was a beautiful animation Arrow especially the sunset flip at the end that looks really hard to do and I loved the reaction by Jomo. Really really good job from you. I only wished you would have closer camera angles so I could see the animation's detail better.
All of these animations were really creative and extreme I loved each one. Fantastic match up here it was very hard to choose the best but after watch all of the animation a few times my vote goes to: Rob.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 3:39:13 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 10:31:34 GMT -5
WHO IS THE MONEY IN THE JABRONI?
Cam: Brilliant animation. The Lionsault was great, even if the impact and reaction were simple. The RKO was also awesome, but I wish you would have Orton a little more to his side when you do them. The reaction was perfect. I really didnt like the second RKO in the way that John barely put any effort into reversing it, like Orton just bounced off. The last move was the best part, I just wish there was more leg movement in both wrestlers. Overall very smooth and good.
Andeh: I like the idea you had, I just feel it could have been done better. The animation was smooth but there were a few stiff parts. The dead reaction from the suplex was fine but you should have had him crunch up a little. The knee drop was stiff, which could have been avoided by better movements in the jump and having the arms move during the fall.
Daniels was a little too fast to me, and the moves he choose made his ani have less movements then some of the others. The were animated fine and the animation itself is smooth but they just arent good enough in a match like this. Bourne needed more of a reaction at the end too.
Rob`s was insane. Everyone was constantly moving and it was just a really fun animation overall. The 450 was great, but shifted a little in the air. The superkick and german were really good, especially with Cara jumping in the background. My only two real complaints were that the positioning looked kinda weird during the C4 setup, but theres not too much that can be done about that. The hurricanrana was also overshot, which bugged me.
Skits was really smooth and really stiff. Theres not too much else I can say about it. Also try putting tape under the table for better breaks, the quick break interrupted the flow of the ani.
You know, I never really thought of Showoff as a big player here until tonight. Tonight he really earned his name. All the RKO`s were great, aside from the first which was a little shaky. I must say that last one was incredible, the only thing that would have made it better was more frames when ziggler changes position.
As much as I love showoff`s animation, it was animated as well as Arrow`s or Rob`s. I think my vote is going to ROB.
|
|
JDP
Main Eventer
WFigs biggest Justin Gabriel fan.
Joined on: Aug 22, 2012 2:09:11 GMT -5
Posts: 3,561
|
Post by JDP on Apr 21, 2013 11:04:32 GMT -5
My vote goes to Arrow.
I thought he had the smoothest animation out of everyones with the least amount of flaws. There was some parts that were a bit stiff and I saw little string at times but his was the best overall. I really like the RKO and the Sunset Flip Powerbomb off of the ladder. I thought the mid air realism of the rko was really nice and I liked how you moved Jericho's and Orton's joints a lot. The Sunset flip powerbomb was pretty smooth, The bend from Bryan in the beginning was realisitic and was nicely done. The flip itself had a smooth turn with good joint movement but the powerbomb from bryan had bryan somewhat stiff and Jomo had good joint movement. The reaction from Jomo was really nice and effective. Runner up had to be Rob, as did others he put a lot of effort into his animation pratically moving 3 figures in different places at a time. My favorite part of Rob ani had to be the 450.
Amazing effort by everyone, and don't think this is the end. All of you will go far.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 3:39:13 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 14:41:34 GMT -5
The way and ranking this match is kinda weird Arrow you had 3 moves and 1 reversal the lionsault was pretty good but it was stiff coming down overall 7 out of 10 The RKO seemed a bit stiff but the reaction was flawless 9 out of 10 The RKO reversal wasn't that good it looked more like a botch plus it seemed like he got knocked out 3 out of 10 The springboard powerbomb was sick as the springboard was great the twisting was flawless and the reaction was great 10 out of 10 Overall 30 out of 40 Rob you had 4 amazing moves The springboard 450 was good but floaty 7 out of 10 The super kick was good but no reaction 7 out of 10 The German suplex was really good a bit fidgety but we couldn't see the reaction 8 out of 10 The hurricanranna was very well executed it had great build up it was very smooth but just very oversold 9 out of 10 Overall 31 out of 40 Show off you had 4 RKOs The first one was pretty stiff and fidgety but good reaction 7 out of 10 2nd one was decent but the the airborne was missing frames 6 out of 10 3rd one was good it was a little stiff one the way down 9 out of 10 4th one was also stiff throughout butthead a sick impact 8 out of 10 Overall 30 out of 40 Holy crap this match was close but ill vote for rob for having the best moves out of the 3 best
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 11, 2024 3:39:13 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 15:13:04 GMT -5
Great Match. Well it came down to Cam and Rob but will go through other guys to as they put a huge effort in.
Daniel - Not your greatest man, sadly not up to the standard of the rest of the animations here. The camera was very shaky throughout which let you down quite a bit. The animation was also quite fast for me. The animation itself I guess was pretty smooth, but the moves were kinda basic i felt. The ladders were also pretty fidgety and shaky throughout so i suggest taping them down.
Skits - This wasn't bad man. The whole thing was pretty smooth throughout, but it was very stiff indeed here bro. You need to make sure you move the joints in every frame and dont ignore some if you get me. I also felt some of it was pretty slow and needed speeding up, i liked the set up to the animation. The table break was pretty choppy i felt and spoilt part of the flow for me a tad. The F5? needed a few more transition frames and was kinda floaty in mid air. Nice Idea though.
Showoff - This was one of your better animations, and certainly a very creative one. The shadows throughout I felt were a bit distracting for me, maybe you should get a better light source? I liked the smoothness of the jump into the first RKO, i felt the height gained was a bit unrealistic and Ortons jup although pretty smooth was a tad floaty for me, I also thought it was just a tad stiff, I really liked the SSP into Rko. I felt Bourne was a bit choppy in his SSP transition. I like Ortons movements though bro. I wasnt a fan of how the other guys not receiving a move just stood there. There movements were quite fidgety hence so kinda spoilt the flow and realism. RKO on Cody was the best. Was in anything juust a tad fidgety but in general pretty good. Liked the pushing away of the ladder. I felt Dolph's fall was a bit floaty though and a bit stiff but in general decent. I liked the oversell, pretty smooth.
Andeh - I liked this sir. I liked the punches at the start, hardys movements were smooth which was good. I felt Evans reaction to the punches was a tad figety though. Liked the bend up of Angle into the suplex. It was smooth and flowed well. Maybe if he held on a bit longer before he released it would have been slightly better but thats just me. I liked the suplex and the impact to the matt, i felt it was a tad stiff in places but nothing major there. I liked the struggle of Angle in the ladder area, and i liked Bournes climb, i did find thought the lighting ot be a bit in consistent. I thought the knee drop was a bit stiff in places, maybe you could have had the arms move a bit more. I also thought Bournes reaction was a tad fast. Nice though.
Right now it comes down to Cam and Rob.
Rob - This was really good bro. Loved the set up here, looked really good. I liked how u moved everyone in the match at the start, very smooth job done there. 450 was very good, nice spacing, great flow and very smooth indeed. Table break was great and I loved how Eddie crawled out of the ring scene. I really liked the superkick, had nice impact and again had a great flow, no sign of fidgetyness to me. I felt though that the Garbage can and chair were a bit fidgety in parts, but that wasnt to distracting. Suplex was great, nice and smooth and had another great flow, i am amazed you manage to get JoMo standing up and Sin Cara springboarding so smooth whilst holding another bit of string for the suplex move, nicely done. I liked the fighting of Jo Mo and Cara on the Bridge. Was smooth and had great joint movements. I felt that the fall of Cara into the Hurricnanrana postion lacked just a frame or to to me though.I liked the take of of the rana, but i did feel that it was slightly overshot. However, i was a fan of the oversell movements, it was unique and had a nice flow and was smooth to me. I loved this also cause of the high pace action involved.
Cam - This was excellent also Cameron. Set up looked really good as well Cam. I liked Jericho's taunt before the lionsault, that was really nice. I felt maybe you could have moved the other guys in the match throughout like Rob did though. Springboard moonsualt was nicely done, nice springboard up, nice joint movements and nice impact and nice reaction although simple but realistic. RKO was very nice, liked the build up to ithad a nice flow, and was smooth throughout. Nice impact and good simple but realistic reaction. String throughout kinda bugged be a bit but nothing to bad. Liked ortons get up from the RKO, and liked the movements towards JoMo. I felt the missed RKO was a bit fast for me, i also felt JoMo could have done more to try and avoid the rko by pushing hi away rather than Orton just falling. The ladder climb was terrific, it was very smooth and had a nice flow and the realism was sick. The smoothness of the sunset flip was very nice, great joint movement, and had a great flow. Well Done. I felt the pace of the animation coul; dhave been increased slightly to maybe make it seem more chaotic if you get me, as I felt some of the pauses with the taunts were a tad slow. However as I have said the moves were executed in general pretty damn well.
This is very close between Cam and Rob again. Might be one of the toughest matches I have had to make a judgement on. After much thinking i am going to VOTE ROB just. Reason being that i felt that both men had a weak move that being the reversed RKO and the mid air over shot huricanrana. I liked Robs pace better and how everything came thick and fast as well as the fact he was doing tough movements with several figures at one time. Great match guys and Sorry Cam, it was very very close, and I just went with my gut with the reason above.
|
|
BION
Mid-Carder
Joined on: Jun 29, 2012 17:43:44 GMT -5
Posts: 446
|
Post by BION on Apr 22, 2013 10:17:45 GMT -5
my vote goes to arrow. I thought he had the best animation with the best flow and reactions. Although I did see string at times it was a really good animation just like the others, in some places you moved the joints well and in some you didn't. But that's two flaws and that was the least out of everyone. I thought Rob and showoff were the closest ones to beating arrow in this match. good effort and creativity by everyone.
|
|
wwestevo07
Main Eventer
4 Time WF Ani World Champion
Joined on: Oct 17, 2006 14:15:28 GMT -5
Posts: 1,142
|
Post by wwestevo07 on Apr 22, 2013 12:43:32 GMT -5
Arrow: The lionsault was smooth and looked good but Jericho's legs looked a little stip coming down before hitting it and the reaction was smooth but could have been more impact. The RKO to Jericho looked great. The second one was alright but looked more like Orton just fell rather than Morrison pushing him off. The ladder climb looked pretty good but didn't like how Morrison was just standing on the ladder for a bit like he was waiting for Bryan. I loved the sunset powerbomb, it was smooth, looked good and the reaction was nice.
Andeh: The suplex off the ladder was smooth and looked great. Not sure why you did the zoom effect there, was a bit weird. The ladder climb was good and the stomp looked pretty good too. The guy on the ladder didn't have much of a reaction and the reactions by Bourne and jeff were pretty good but maybe could have give jeff a longer reaction or something.
Dan: The ani was pretty fast through, would of looked a little better slowed down a bit. The move at the start was good but a little stiff but you are animating with basics lol. Didn't really like the camera angle change. The move by Bourne was good, smooth and flowed well but again just a little stiff and Bourne needed much more of a reaction.
Rob: Loved how you had everyone moving at the start. I loved the 450 and the reaction to it. The thing that really impressed me was that the action never stopped, like during the superkick Morrison was moving and getting up and Cara was jumping before the suplex even ended. The fact that everyone was constantly moving really made this ani great. The buildup to the hurricarona was great but the actually move when Cara was going through the air seemed kind of floaty or something or like he went way too far.
Skits: The ani was really smooth but was also really slow and seemed a bit stiff in most places. Didn't like how Brock was standing there holding cena for half of the ani and the cena was pretty stiff coming down from the F5. One thing i did like in the ani was the elbow by punk, just looked pretty good.
ShowOff: Very creative ani, good job on the idea. The RKO's were done pretty well and the reactions were nice. There was just a few stiff parts like when ziggler was falling, would of looked better if he was moving around a little more while falling. The reaction was a nice oversell but it seemed like it was missing a frame or something. The SSP also seemed like it was missing a frame but it did look pretty good.
For me this came down to Rob and Arrow. Both great ani's but the thing that makes Rob's a better ani is the fact that the action never really stopped and everyone was always moving but in Arrows during each move the other guys were only moving a little but not doing very much so that's what did it for me
Vote: Rob
|
|