person you liked in once company but not in another company

Great topic....The Giant is defo a great example & one I agree with.

I have to go with Waltman here. I enjoyed the 123 Kid but I just couldnt get into him as Syxx & then....thought he was great as X Pac until about May 2000 when I became really sick of him.

Goldberg is another. Loved him in WCW but after a month or so? WWEs booking made me give zero craps about him. I thought he'd win the EC at Summerslam but when he didnt it was meh again!!

Goldberg is one. Liked him in WCW, but in the wwe I just liked his entrance.

Kevin Nash is another. Couldn’t care any less for him in the WWE as Diesel, but liked him in WCW as Kevin Nash.

This. Big fan of his in ECW, when he went to the WWF, I thought he was going to be huge. About a week or two in, they killed him off, and he was never the same. 

I feel like a lot of WWF guys I didn’t like in WCW. I was a huge Bossman fan but I can’t stand him as Big Bubba in WCW. John Tenta was another one. Great as Earthquake but horrible as Shark (lol) in WCW.

AJ Styles. He was awesome in TNA but I dont like him with long hair, beard and ripoff DMX theme song in WWE.

Off the top of my head, Jon Moxley in AEW. I don't our right hate him there, but the longer he's there, the less I like him. Between stupid crap he says in interviews outside, to his obsession with bleeding and everything has to be weapons, he's just gotten annoying to me.

I'm a huge Mox fan but if we had got his AEW gimmick during his WWE run the entire company would've been on fire.

He's by far one of the most gripping guys on the roster.

Nash is also a good one. I was in & out on WWF at the time but I didn't care about Nash until he turned up in WCW with Hall.

Nash is an interesting one. I liked him as Diesel in WWF, LOVED him as Nash in WCW…
But when he returned to WWE in 2002, specifically when he came back after the nWo disbanded, idk, he just wasn’t the same guy that was main eventing WCW shows. It didn’t feel like Kevin Nash from WCW in WWE.

That happened a lot and I’m gonna say WWF to WWE has the biggest examples for me of the topic. Guys like HBK even…LOVED WWF Shawn Michaels, but WWE HBK just didn’t feel like the same guy. All the guys that came from WWF felt like shells in WWE. Almost like when you create a wrestler in a video game. It looks like them, has all the moves…but the nuances are missing.

Scott Steiner is another complex example. Liked original early 90s WCW version, liked WWF Steiner even more, thought he was even BETTER when he went back to WCW in the late 90s…but WWE Scott Steiner just felt like another empty shell. But then he redeemed himself because TNA Scott Steiner was highly enjoyable again haha.