Good issue to have, but need help.

Yeah I'd go with Rice. As you saw from my thread, I too have Rice and seeing him on my bench with double digit points for the last two weeks was not to fun (even though I won both games). Plus the Giants pass D isn't all that great because of their injuries. That coupled with the Seahawks mostly throwing the ball because of frequently being down in the game, is a recipe for success.

Colston I would say needs another week to prove himself. Brees has a bunch of options to throw the ball to, so Colston getting all his normal touches isn't currently necessary for them to still be good. Williams would be a decent option, but I'm expecting (and hoping lol) that the Bucs will be running the ball alot in this game after Blount's performance last week.

So yeah I think Rice is definitely your best option of the three.