|
|
Post by Andeh on Nov 18, 2013 11:39:43 GMT -5
"Tag partners now turned opponents" World Heavyweight ChampionshipShowoff(C) Vs. Josh -Stip 1: Bloody Sunday -Stip 2: Top Rope Angle Slam Showoff:  i.minus.com/ibvucKsNc68676.gif i.minus.com/if55c8dZMPYFC.gifJosh:  i.minus.com/inkfjXNMo5WRU.gif i.minus.com/ibggY1y1J9kIZ1.gifHow to vote on matches No polls or bad replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following: 1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?) 2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. However you need to compare with the other animations in the match. Put thought into your votes, don't just say who you are voting and leave a sentence, put some effort in. 3) Forum status must be above Jobber If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10, but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
If a title match ends in a draw, the champion retains. VOTING ENDS IN 72 HOURS |
|
|
|
Post by wwextreme25 on Nov 18, 2013 12:01:22 GMT -5
omg what a match....you guys pulled out all the stops! Literally you guys have made near flawless animations proud of you both!
Showoff:
Bloody Sunday
Good effort man, looked to be a hard move. The pick up was great and everything but i didnt like the delayed reaction, couldve done with more work there! However, thats about the only flaw i saw, and im being picky. Maybe have punk do a reaction as well or something? Other than that, the joint movement was done exceptionally. Loved the effort you did in that, maybe a bit more impact wouldve looked nice like on josh's but great effort man, loved it. 8.5/10
Angle slam
Again a nice animation, however i thought this was yoru weaker of the two. I didnt like how stiff cesaro's legs were in the fall. He didnt really jump he just fell, and that kinda gave off a lack of impact. Good effort otherwise tho. Punks reaction was amazing, loved the realism in that, cesaro couldve had a better one and again, it had lack of impact imo. 8/10
OVERALL: 16.5/20
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Josh
Bloody Sunday
Wow you pulled out all the stops on these stips man well done. Wouldve loved some sort of build up, whether it be a punch or whatever, just to make it look good but nonetheless i enjoyed it. The lift u pwas great and the way you animated edge fall into the move was bang on imo. Looked very realistic. Ziggler wasnt stiff and a love the rope bounce...really looked good and realistic man great job. Cant find any flaws really other than maybe have edge do a bit more at the end? 9/10
Angle slam
Loved this one man. Wouldve been nice, again, if you added some sort of small build up, a punch then the angle slam i dunno. Rollins was a little stiff through mid air but i liked the height and air time you gave the figures, looked really good man great job. Also Rollins oversell reaction was great and the rope bounce made for an awesome impact which i really enjoyed. Loved it man great job. 9/10
OVERALL: 18/20
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vote: Josh. Fully deserved, had the most realistic joint movements and fluidity in his animations. showoff, minor flaws let you down which normally wouldnt have, but josh brought everything to the table so it was hard to compete with!
|
|
|
|
Post by Jack on Nov 18, 2013 12:08:39 GMT -5
Right this is the one I wanted to vote on.
Stip 1
Showoff - Ok, loved the realism of the pick up here with the movements in the legs of Punk when lifting up the weight. I did feel however that Bryans legs were a tad stiff as well as the lift up to vertical almost felt a bit lacking in a couple frames. Realism wise I didnt like how Punk jumped up into the impact. He doesn't really do that, he more goes straight down Devitt. I liked the movements by Bryan in the fall and the impact was very nice. Really liked the bounce up by Bryan though, nicely done. 8/10.
Josh - Ok, I really liked the flow of the ani here, it was realistic in the way he actually does the move, that being pretty quick. I didn't see any stiffness in the legs of Ziggler here at all, very smooth. Loved the movements of Edge here when he was dropping Ziggler, they were so smooth and had a great flow to them. Once more your realism is bang on with the impact, when he does the move that is how the impact is. The ending bit was a tad fidgety with the camera change but nothing major. 9/10
Stip 2
Showoff - This was much better than your first one. I loved the lift up here, very smooth and had a great flow to it. Really liked how you had Punk moving throughout here, that was great realism. The flow of the animation was really well done, it was smooth and I loved the movements in Cesaro. However, I did feel Cesaro just kinda fell for me, didnt really like that. The shadow was a tad annoying for me but it was minimal. The speed was nice throughout however I felt the animation lacked impact for me. 8.5/10
Josh - Another great job. I would have liked if you had included some kind off build up, but you both didn't do it so doesn't matter really. Rollins seemed a little stiff through mid air but I liked your attempt at trying to move him, looked pretty good. Realism of the air time was very good for me here and i liked the movements pf Ziggler also. Impact was better than Showoffs here i have to say and the reactions and the joint movements of the reactions were very good. Loved the touch with Ziggler pulling up his knee pad also. 8.75/10.
Josh - 17.75
Showoff - 16.5
Vote Josh. Fully deserved here mate, 2 of your best animations, very impressive.
|
|
|
|
Post by el torro on Nov 18, 2013 15:48:48 GMT -5
Well deserved win, Josh. Really like Rollin's reaction.
|
|
|
|
Post by Scotty on Nov 18, 2013 16:53:06 GMT -5
Shitshit: Wish you would have made the underhook, but thats fine. The liftup was alright. Bryan was a little stiff, didn't like how far back punk went though. He would have fallen on his bum. The jump up could have used a bend down too. The move was smooth though. The reaction was alright, and although the bounce was nice, he went in such a strange way and it didn't really look well TBH. Really fidgety on the top rope. A bend would have been nice. The move appeared stiff mid air, although it could just be the positioning the camera was at, not allowing Punk to really be seen. The reaction was nice. JushyMana..: The Liftup was pretty fast, wish edge bended more and lifted. Dolph wasn't stiff in the move and edge wasn't really. The finish was nicer and had a better impact that crapShits. No bend again  , The move was really smooth though. Only flaws really are theres a few signs of fidgetyness like at the beginning and during the reaction by both men. Really like how you had Rollie Pollie Oli bounce though. The touch of dolph pulling up his pad was really nice too. REALLY tough, but gonna have to go with Josh here as his moves had a few less flaws. Really great match guys. Josh deserves this reign just as much as ShittyMcShitcrapdeserved to retain. You shouold both be really proud of yourselves. Best animators on the board today. |
|
KKD
Superstar
"Never wound what you can't kill."
Joined on: Oct 2, 2013 18:50:48 GMT -5
Posts: 866 
|
Post by KKD on Nov 18, 2013 17:18:51 GMT -5
Showoff
Bloody Sunday:
Nice work man. The liftup was smooth as usual and so was the rest of the animation. The joint movement was done very nicely and I liked the rope bounce and reaction, although Punk didnt have much of one as he just kinda laid there. Great job nonetheless.
Angle Slam:
Not a bad animation, obviously not your best work. The flow was great as usual but during the animation, Cesaro's legs were stiff in the fall. Punk's reaction was very realistic. Not much to this animation so good job.
Josh
Bloody Sunday:
Great job dude. The lift up was very fluid and the joint movements were superb, it looked very realistic. Both figures weren't stiff but I felt the rope bounce was too much. It was...just too bouncy for my taste...really looked good and realistic man great job. The reactions were both nice although Edge didn't have much of one. Great job.
Angle Slam:
Another great animation from you. Both figures were a bit stiff throughout mid air. I didn't really like the big bounce or oersell but it was smooth and had nice fluidity. looked really good man great job. Ziggler was a bit fidgety at the end.
Vote: Josh
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Nov 18, 2024 2:28:09 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 18, 2013 20:53:51 GMT -5
Showoff
Bloody Sunday:
One of your best ani's man. the whole thing flowed very well like usual. I felt that there should be a pause with the first frame so the viewer can get ready but thats a small detail. the lift up was very smooth but a bit stiff and lacked like a frame. the fall was very fluid and had great joint movement. I seriously love the impact on this one, I don't know what it is but it looks very good. not much else to say man - 8.2/10
Angle Slam:
another good animation. the whole animation was very fluid. the pickup was smooth but a bit stiff in my opinion. the launch/fall was also very fluid and had good joint movement. the impact was great and the reaction was also well done - 7.5
- 15.8/20
Josh
Bloody Sunday:
very good animation from you but not your best. the pickup had a great amount of frames which means it was very fluid but, imo, it was pretty stiff.
the fall was also very fluid but I felt that christian was stiff. the reaction was also pretty good but at the end, imo, christian and dolph were a bit fidgety. I didn't like the zoom, it would have been better with out it - 7/10
Angle Slam:
wow. this is truly one of your best animation imo. the whole flowed very well with a great amount of frames. the pick up and launch was smooth but seth's legs were stiff, you could have moved them more. the fall was very well executed, if anything a tiny bit stiff imo. The impact was just beautiful. the rope bounce and bounce by rollins looked awesome and the reaction by seth was good but I felt that dolph was a tad fidgety. great job man - 8.5/10
- 15.5/20
Extremely close but I have to..
VOTE: SHOWOFF
|
|
GAm3r357
Mid-Carder
Los Matadores.
Joined on: May 5, 2012 6:57:08 GMT -5
Posts: 111
|
Post by GAm3r357 on Nov 19, 2013 13:54:20 GMT -5
Good match guys!. Showoff: Bloody Sunday;; great animation here man. Saw hardly no flaws at all and everything was done to a great standard. Bryans reaction was great and i loved the realism of everything. Nice impact, great smoothness and good joint movements. maybe a BIT more bend in bryans legs in the lift but thats me being harsh. Great job. 9/10 Avalanch Angle Slam;; Loved this one. Again, great realism in the move. Maybe a bit more impact wouldve made it look perfect as that let you slightly down. I think this is your weaker ani of the two, but still a great one nonetheless. Enjoyed the fall and im sure the stringwork was mad to work with but you pulled it off well  Again, a bit more bend in the joints wouldve made it a lot more realistic, but still enjoyed the move. 8.5/10 Total: 17.5/20 Josh: Bloody Sunday;; Loved this animation man. you did a great job. The smoothness was top notch as usual, and i loved the lighting. Didnt like how edge had hardly any bend on the lift up, kinda made it look odd same with ziggler. Also ziggler's legs were very stiff in mid air on the fall. However impact was awesome and the flow was great. 8/10 Avalanche Angle Slam;; Nice animation man. ilike how you moved ziggler well through mid air mustve been a tough move to get right. Rollins remained very stiff throughout the flight of mid air tho which looked unrealistic. Again, the flow, smoothness and lighting was fine, and i especially loved the reaction/oversell rollins did made it look great. Nice job. 9/10 Vote: showoff, i preferred his joint movements better to josh's and thought the moves themselves looked more realistic. Great match guys. |
|
|
|
Post by Andeh on Nov 20, 2013 20:12:40 GMT -5
In future just leave it to me. |
|
