Samoa joe flesh tone ideas?

This is the wrong section for that, but I understand where you are coming from with this. Getting the tattoos off is timely thing, but patience is key, but since you are planning on painting the body to a color that's similar to Brodus Clay's, then I really don't feel that taking off the tattoos is needed as that would just involve more work for you. Have you worked with acrylic paints or have done some customizing? We have a great custom support section here that gives you all the knowhow on what to do here.

Maybe a Legends Dusty Rhodes with whatever that is on his stomach removed?

Oh right, I see. Best bet is probably Citadel, you can get it from the Games Workshop. By any Caucasian tone, and mix it with white, black, red, etc until you get a match. However, you might get lucky and have an instant match straight out of the pot.

No problem.