|
|
Post by Cass on Nov 1, 2014 14:55:18 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by Slim on Nov 1, 2014 16:18:29 GMT -5
Josh: I really like your work, it flowed well and had great joints movements. Your camera quality is also fantastic.
Mighty Menace: I also enjoyed your work, it was pretty good, I like the joints movements, etc. But Josh's were more realistic and had a better flow.
Vote: Josh
|
|
Tyler Black
Main Eventer
the former #1 Tyler Black fan/Tyler F'n Black
Joined on: Jul 19, 2009 15:37:40 GMT -5
Posts: 2,544
|
Post by Tyler Black on Nov 1, 2014 16:33:05 GMT -5
damn no shows I was really looking forward to some good competition. On the other hand I got lucky since I had to hand in a pose from one of my old shows, wanted to do the POUNCE reversed into a European uppercut, didn't get a chance to film it.
Now on to the match.
Josh vs Mighty Menace. should be great.
Josh: Great crisp pics. love the shot over cesaro's shoulder. Nice posing, thought you should have picked up Sheamus' arms more when he was running. Helluva kick was done nicely but I feel like you could have used a transition pic where sheamus picks his leg up like Mighty menace had. can see a little bit of string but nothing really obvious. Loved Cesaro's reaction very nicely done. Didn't really like how you had sheamus pick him up. felt like there should have been a transition or two between cesaro holding his jaw on the mat and sheamus picking him up. also felt like the way you had sheamus pick cesaro up should have resulted in Cesaro's legs being inside the turn buckles not outside of them, or sheamus should have picked cesaro up more like a suplex for his legs to end in that position. The BRAIN BUSTAHHHH was beautifully done loved your posing of Sheamus on it. Cesaro could have used a transition pic between hitting the turnbuckle and his fall to the outside.
8/10
Mighty Meance: not sure picking a basic to work with was your smartest move, interested to see how you can make it work. Can see some string, but not really bad. loved how you set up the helluva kick with corner powerbomb nice. Sweet running shots, so far you're handling the posing of that basic Brodie well. Helluva kick was great love your use of transition pics like every step in the run sequence and the lifting of brodie's leg before he takes Gargano's head off. Very interesting way to set up the BRAIN BUSTAHHH I like it. great job so far. Felt like Brody's way down on the brain bustahhhh could have used some tweaking like lifting brodie's right knee slightly. Loved gargano's reaction and Brodie's crazy eyes at the end. very well done.
8.5/10
VOTE: Mighty Meance very slightly gets the W, because while Josh's pose was great, I did love Mighty's use of transition pics and how he handled posing that basic. Great match
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Jun 16, 2024 19:05:17 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2014 23:25:46 GMT -5
I wasn't too fond of Josh's, mostly because of the first 5 pics seeming pretty stiff.
Richard's on the other hand, had surprisingly smooth transitioning and pics throughout, even tho Harper/Brodie Lee was a basic.
Vote: Mighty Menace
|
|
|
|
Post by Sound888 on Nov 4, 2014 0:24:38 GMT -5
Very good match. My vote goes to Josh for this one. Even though it wasn't as solid of a sequence as Mighty Menace's there were some key things that Josh had in his sequence that stood out, which made me pick his as the better pose.
What I didn't like about Mighty's pose is that it had too much going on before the actual stip, which was just the kick and brainbuster. I felt like that took away from the brainbuster at the end. I didn't like how Gargano flew to the top rope after the kick. It would make sense for Gargano to be knocked out - then to have Brodie Lee lift him up onto the top turnbuckle, which was how Josh transitioned it.
I also like Claudio's bump to the outside in Josh's better than Gargano's in Mighty's. If you want to get technical about it - Gargano was falling inwards towards the ring, and for him to fall to the outside was very unnatural. If you wanted him to fall to the outside, I would have kept him vertical - which is what Josh did in his pose.
Josh gets a point for the good angle in pic #1. Sheamus being hung up in the ropes in pic #4 (which Mighty also did, but had a bad angle of it). And pic #10, which I knew I was already voting for him as soon as I saw it. Absolutely perfect.
Good job, Mighty, nonetheless. Thank you both for making the poses.
|
|
|
|
Post by c-scope on Nov 11, 2014 23:17:23 GMT -5
They were both cool but gotta say mighty menace also could some one explain this to me
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Jun 16, 2024 19:05:17 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 1, 2014 14:46:29 GMT -5
Mighty Menace.
|
|
|
|
Post by Wicked on Dec 16, 2014 0:07:10 GMT -5
Is this ever going to be FINISHED! Gosh Cass It'd be awesome if you informed us on what's going on with this? |
|
|
|
Post by Cass on Dec 16, 2014 2:36:24 GMT -5
Woulda been neat if there was more votes. It appears few care about this place, since more people complain than actually take part. Thanks for your concern!
|
|
|
|
Post by brm on Jan 4, 2015 13:38:41 GMT -5
This was actually pretty close.
JOSH - Pic quality is great and clean, but this all comes down to the posing. Taking the whole pose into consideration, pic 10 is really the only great shot in here. Basically, it comes down to a whole sequence with only one real money shot. To me, I don't really see the effort in the other shots. For example, it doesn't look like you used string for Sheamus' running shot. There's also no mid air reaction shot of Claudio after the impact of the brainbuster. He goes from turnbuckle to floor with no transition.
Mighty Menace - Your string editing was a bit shoddy, but I can see you used string throughout the pose. I especially like how you used a basic figure, but hid the limitations of the articulation by using string for simple things like him holding his gut in the first picture. You also have lots of shots between your "money" shots, showing me you put more effort into the pose overall, and didn't just get those stand out shots.
All things considered, my vote is for Mighty Menace. JOSH has the better production value, but I saw more effort in Mighty Menace's pose. JOSH's pose to me breaks down to just one single great pic, but Mighty Menance appears to have spread his efforts over his whole sequence, using string for set ups and reactions and not just the main brainbuster mid air shot. Good job to both, though.
|
|
|
|
Post by Wicked on Jan 4, 2015 20:44:42 GMT -5
Mighty Menace - Your string editing was a bit shoddy, but I can see you used string throughout the pose. I especially like how you used a basic figure, but hid the limitations of the articulation by using string for simple things like him holding his gut in the first picture. You also have lots of shots between your "money" shots, showing me you put more effort into the pose overall, and didn't just get those stand out shots. All things considered, my vote is for Mighty Menace. JOSH has the better production value, but I saw more effort in Mighty Menace's pose. JOSH's pose to me breaks down to just one single great pic, but Mighty Menance appears to have spread his efforts over his whole sequence, using string for set ups and reactions and not just the main brainbuster mid air shot. Good job to both, though. Thank you so much. FIW is one of my favourite fed. |
|
[/div] 
[/div] 
