Who was the best member of the shield?

I can't answer that, I liked all three equally as a unit.

Seth Rollins, my brother...

I'm not sure whether you got the reference or not, ya mark.

Rollins has always been my favorite.

My answer hasn't changed, Rollins.

Depends how you look at it. As a unit they were pretty damn perfect. Rollins was IMO the key to their ridiculously consistent high match quality, Ambrose is frankly just Dean ing Ambrose which is reason enough, alongside the fact that he's by leaps and bounds the best talker and character (again IMO), while Reigns for me seemed to get the most out of the Shield between the three of them. Having 2 well rounded guys like Rollins and Ambrose around allowed him to basically be the exclamation point of the group in a way, as they protected his weaknesses as a wrestler and talker, but accentuated the fact that he's cool as crap, as well as being honestly one of the best hot tag guys in recent memory.

I'm big fan of all 3, but Ambrose is my definite favorite. I worry about Reigns though, no doubt in my mind that he's received the superman treatment for quite a while now. I don't like the idea of Cena being replaced by Samoan Cena.

Roman Reigns is here.

Seth Rollins is here.












Virgil is here.
Gobbeldy Gooker is here.




Dean Ambrose is here.

Agreed man. These are my sentiments exactly. I recently re-watched Shield vs Wyatt's from Elimination Chamber and all 3 guys brought it in that match in different ways.

I liked Roman Reigns a little bit more but All 3 were on the same level and all brought something to the group.